Loyalty & Rewards
7 Best S Loyalty Alternatives for Shopify in 2027
Most merchants start looking for S Loyalty alternatives when the bill catches up with them. At 500 orders a month, the only S Loyalty plan that fits is Premium at $119.99, and it still has no VIP tiers, no Shopify POS support and no built-in referrals.
I compared seven alternatives on what they add, how the bill changes as orders rise and how much of the move each team takes off your hands. Love Loyalty is the closest fit for growing stores with VIP tiers, referrals and POS on its $79 Growth plan. Stores doing fewer than 100 orders a month may have little reason to leave S Loyalty’s Free plan.
What are the best S Loyalty alternatives?
Your reason for leaving matters more than a single overall ranking. A store worried about rising costs needs a different shortlist from one that wants VIP tiers, POS or help with migration.
- For a growing store that wants all-in-one native loyalty app: Love Loyalty, because Growth includes VIP tiers, referrals, POS and wallet passes for $79/month.
- For a fixed bill at any volume: BON, because Growth costs $129/month with no order limit.
- For the lowest price with VIP and POS: Froonze, at $10/month for 500 orders and $60/month with no limit.
- For a done-for-you move: BLOY, because its team migrates point balances and tiers for free on every plan.
- For staying put: S Loyalty still makes sense under 100 orders a month on the Free plan, or when you also sell on BigCommerce.
I checked every price below on 12 November 2026. Our list of the best Shopify loyalty apps covers the wider field, and this is how these seven compare.
| App | Rating | Price | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Love Loyalty Program & Rewards | 5.0 (428 reviews) | $0 to $399/month | VIP, referrals and POS in one app |
| BON Loyalty Program & Rewards | 5.0 (1,987 reviews) | $0 to $129/month, Plus custom | A flat bill at any order volume |
| Froonze VIP Loyalty & Wishlist | 5.0 (274 reviews) | $0 to $60/month (loyalty plugin) | VIP tiers and POS on a small budget |
| BLOY Loyalty Points & Rewards | 5.0 (845 reviews) | $0 to $129/month, plus overage | A done-for-you migration |
| CWILL Loyalty & Referrals | 4.9 (800 reviews) | $0 to $229/month | Multi-language stores |
| Rivo: Loyalty Program, Rewards | 4.7 (1,441 reviews) | $0 to $499/month | DTC brands with a big marketing stack |
| Otter Loyalty & Rewards | 4.6 (22 reviews) | $0 to $15/month, plus overage | Every feature on a $15 plan |
| S Loyalty and Rewards Program (for reference) | 4.4 (235 reviews) | $0 to $119.99/month, custom above 1,000 orders | Small stores that only need points |
Why Shopify merchants look for S Loyalty alternatives
S Loyalty has been on the Shopify App Store since 2012, and it does the basics well. Its themes look polished, and you can choose whether points arrive on payment or on fulfilment. The reasons merchants leave come from how the plans are built, so a support ticket won’t fix them.
- The order bands get expensive quickly. Basic costs $19.99/month for 50 orders, half of what the Free plan allows. Pro covers 350 orders for $69.99/month, so a store doing 500 orders has to pay $119.99/month for Premium. S Loyalty sets your band from the average of the last 12 months, and when you pass a limit the programme stops until you upgrade.
- VIP tiers, POS and referrals aren’t in the app. No S Loyalty plan includes VIP tiers or Shopify POS support. Referrals run through ReferralCandy, a separate app with its own fee. Every app on this list has VIP tiers and referrals built in, and six of the seven work with POS.
- Support replies are hard to get. GREAT DOG CO., an S Loyalty user for more than 11 years, wrote in May 2026 that three contacts in one week went unanswered, and Eagles Wings Natural Health described the same problem in June 2024 in its review of the app. Priority email support starts on Premium, and there’s no live chat. Magicbean’s review study found support comes up in 46.7% of one- and two-star loyalty app reviews, more than any other theme.
Switching becomes easier to justify once you pass 350 orders a month and reach the $119.99 plan, or when you need VIP tiers or in-store points. Below 100 orders, S Loyalty can still be a sensible choice. Its Free plan includes three rewards, a birthday bonus and five storefront languages. It also runs on BigCommerce, which matters if you sell on both platforms.
How did I pick these alternatives?
I used S Loyalty’s missing features and order limits as the starting point. Each alternative had to solve at least one of those problems. I then checked the details that affect the switch.
- VIP tiers and referrals in the app, and the plan they start on
- Shopify POS support and its price
- Cost at 500, 1,000 and 2,000 orders a month
- What happens when you pass the order limit
- Who moves your members and point balances
The Shopify loyalty app pricing comparison covers more apps if you want options beyond these seven.
Which S Loyalty alternatives are worth switching to?
The seven apps below are in the order I’d try them as an S Loyalty user. Each one is compared against S Loyalty’s current plans.
1. Love Loyalty: Best for VIP, referrals and POS in one app
Rating: 5.0 (428 reviews) | Price: $0 to $399/month | Free trial: 14 days
Love Loyalty is the most straightforward upgrade for stores that have outgrown S Loyalty’s order bands and basic feature set. At 1,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty Growth costs $79 and covers up to 2,000 orders. S Loyalty charges $119.99 for Premium at the same volume, without VIP tiers or POS.
Love Loyalty is an all-in-one loyalty app with the Built for Shopify badge, aimed at growing stores and Shopify Plus brands. Customer feedback adds another useful clue. In Magicbean’s sample of 186 written reviews, support appeared in 60.2% and rewards in 52.2%, with no one- or two-star reviews.
Why choose Love Loyalty over S Loyalty:
- VIP tiers, bonus campaigns, paid memberships and B2B programmes on Growth ($79/month)
- A referral programme built in on every plan, Free included, so there’s no ReferralCandy fee
- Shopify POS earning and redemption from Professional ($12/month), with Apple and Google Wallet passes on Growth
- Points redeemed in the cart, without a pop-up widget
- Free migration on Growth and Plus
Where S Loyalty still wins
Love Loyalty keeps VIP tiers off the $12 Professional plan, so a small store that wants tiers pays $79. Past 2,000 orders, Growth adds $15 per 100, which puts a 3,000-order store at $229 or on Plus at $399. S Loyalty also runs on BigCommerce, which matters for stores selling on both platforms.
Pricing:
- Free: $0/month for 150 orders, no overage
- Professional: $12/month for 500 orders, no overage
- Growth: $79/month for 2,000 orders, then $15 per 100
- Plus: $399/month with no order limit
Paid memberships carry a 1.8% transaction fee on Growth and 0.8% on Plus.
Best for: Growing stores between 500 and 2,000 orders a month that want VIP tiers, referrals and POS on one $79 plan.
2. BON: Best for a flat bill at any order volume
Rating: 5.0 (1,987 reviews) | Price: $0 to $129/month, Plus custom | Free trial: 7 days
BON is the closest match to how S Loyalty bills, with one fixed price and no charge per extra order. BON Growth costs $129/month with no order limit. A store at 1,000 orders pays about $9 more than on S Loyalty Premium, and a store at 5,000 orders still pays $129 while S Loyalty moves to a custom quote from $199.99.
BON is a Canadian app with the Built for Shopify badge and a reply on every low-star review. Magicbean’s review study found support in 76.3% of BON’s 186 written reviews. BON and Love Loyalty were also the two apps switching merchants named most often, with 8 reviews each.
Why choose BON over S Loyalty:
- VIP tiers and B2B tiers on Growth ($129/month) with no order cap
- Shopify POS earning and redemption from Basic ($29/month)
- A referral programme on every plan, Free included
- Points redemption at checkout on Shopify Plus, on every plan
- 250+ storefront languages from Basic, against S Loyalty’s five
Where S Loyalty still wins
Below Growth, BON charges $50/month for points on specific collections or products and $10/month to exclude customers by tag. S Loyalty includes customer exclusion on Pro at $69.99. BON’s trial is 7 days against S Loyalty’s 14, and one trial covers every plan.
Pricing:
- Free: $0/month for 150 orders
- Starter: $15/month for 300 orders
- Basic: $29/month for 500 orders
- Growth: $129/month with no order limit
- Plus: custom quote
No plan charges overage. Above a plan’s limit, you move up a plan.
Best for: Stores above 1,000 orders a month that want VIP tiers and a bill that stays at $129 as they grow.
3. Froonze: Best for VIP tiers and POS on a small budget
Rating: 5.0 (274 reviews) | Price: $0 to $60/month (loyalty plugin) | Free trial: 14 days
Froonze costs the least of any app here with VIP tiers and POS. Its Advanced plan costs $10/month for 500 orders and includes VIP tiers, referrals and POS. At the same 500 orders, S Loyalty charges $119.99 for Premium without any of the three.
Froonze started as a customer accounts app and now sells loyalty, wishlist, reviews and accounts as separate plugins. It has the Built for Shopify badge. Magicbean’s review study found support in 81.5% of Froonze’s 108 written reviews and customisation in 38.0%, with no one- or two-star reviews in its sample.
Why choose Froonze over S Loyalty:
- VIP tiers with tier-specific earning rules, referrals and POS on Advanced ($10/month)
- Customer and sales-channel exclusion on Premium ($30/month), where S Loyalty needs Pro at $69.99
- Points for orders placed before install
- No order limit on Unlimited ($60/month)
- Rewards paid as native Shopify store credit
Where S Loyalty still wins
S Loyalty’s plan price covers everything it offers. Froonze’s $10 to $60 covers loyalty only, and wishlist, reviews and accounts cost extra, up to $180/month for the four at their top tiers. Both of Froonze’s low-star reviews, from 2024, were about finding those plugin prices after installing.
Pricing:
- Free: $0/month for 100 orders
- Advanced: $10/month for 500 orders
- Premium: $30/month for 1,000 orders
- Unlimited: $60/month with no order limit
No plan charges overage. Above a plan’s cap, you upgrade.
Best for: Stores under 1,000 orders a month that want VIP tiers and POS for $30/month or less.
4. BLOY: Best for a done-for-you migration
Rating: 5.0 (845 reviews) | Price: $0 to $129/month, plus overage | Free trial: 14 days
If the migration itself is putting you off switching, BLOY is worth a close look. Its team migrates point balances, VIP tiers and customer history for free on every plan. At 1,000 orders a month, BLOY Growth costs $49 with VIP tiers, against $119.99 for S Loyalty Premium.
BLOY launched in October 2024, so its record is short, but it reached 845 reviews in about two years. Magicbean’s review study found support in 66.8% of BLOY’s 184 written reviews and rewards in 33.7%, with no one- or two-star reviews in its sample.
Why choose BLOY over S Loyalty:
- Free migration of balances, tiers and history, done by BLOY’s team on any plan
- POS, Shopify Flow and all integrations from Launch ($10/month)
- VIP tiers, points on product pages and cart redemption on Growth ($49/month)
- The programme keeps running past your limit, with extra orders billed at a fixed rate
- 20 admin languages
Where S Loyalty still wins
BLOY’s Unlimited plan covers 3,000 orders and then charges $10 per 100, and above 4,500 orders every store needs a custom quote. Our BLOY alternatives cover apps with a published price past that point. Redeeming points at checkout needs both the $129 plan and Shopify Plus.
Pricing:
- Free: $0/month for 200 orders, no overage
- Launch: $10/month for 500 orders, then $15 per 100
- Growth: $49/month for 1,500 orders, then $12 per 100
- Unlimited: $129/month for 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100
- Custom: quote for stores above 3,000 orders
Best for: Stores between 500 and 1,500 orders a month that want VIP tiers at $49 and a migration done for them.
5. CWILL: Best for multi-language stores
Rating: 4.9 (800 reviews) | Price: $0 to $229/month | Free trial: 14 days
If you sell in several languages, CWILL has a practical advantage over most of this list. Its admin comes in 20 languages, and multi-language storefront text starts on Essential at $19/month. At 1,000 orders, CWILL Pro with VIP tiers costs $99/month, which is $20.99 less than S Loyalty Premium.
CWILL was called Loloyal, then TrustWILL Loyalty, and comes from a vendor that also sells product reviews and helpdesk apps. It has the Built for Shopify badge. Magicbean’s review study found support in 36.5% of CWILL’s 104 written reviews and reliability in 8.7%, with 2 one- and two-star reviews in its sample.
Why choose CWILL over S Loyalty:
- 20 admin languages and multi-language storefront text from Essential ($19/month)
- Shopify POS and a loyalty page from Essential
- VIP tiers, points expiry and Klaviyo on Pro (from $69/month)
- A referral programme and review rewards on every plan, Free included
- Receipt scanning on Pro
Where S Loyalty still wins
CWILL’s self-serve plans stop at 3,000 orders, and above that you need an Enterprise quote. When you pass a plan limit, the programme runs for three more days and then pauses until you upgrade or add orders. CWILL’s FAQ also says loyalty data has to be moved manually, with team help for complex moves.
Pricing:
- Free: $0/month for 200 orders, no overage
- Essential: $19/month for 200 orders or $29/month for 500, then $20 per 100
- Pro: $69/month for 500 orders, $99 for 1,000, $169 for 2,000 or $229 for 3,000, then $15 per 100
- Enterprise: custom quote above 3,000 orders
Best for: Multi-language stores between 500 and 2,000 orders a month that want VIP tiers from $69.
6. Rivo: Best for DTC brands with a big marketing stack
Rating: 4.7 (1,441 reviews) | Price: $0 to $499/month | Free trial: 14 days
Rivo makes more sense when loyalty needs to connect with a much larger marketing setup. It connects to Klaviyo, Attentive, Postscript and Gorgias, while S Loyalty lists Langify, Weglot and ReferralCandy. It costs more at mid volume, with Scale at $169/month for 1,000 orders against S Loyalty’s $119.99.
Rivo is a founder-led app that also sells separate Cashback and Accounts products. It doesn’t have the Built for Shopify badge. Magicbean’s review study found support in 82.5% of Rivo’s 126 written reviews and reliability in 25.4%, with 16 one- and two-star reviews in its sample.
Why choose Rivo over S Loyalty:
- VIP tiers, points expiry and bonus campaigns on Scale ($49/month for 400 orders)
- Shopify POS from Essential ($15/month)
- Integrations with Klaviyo, Attentive, Postscript, Gorgias and Shopify Flow
- Checkout extensions and a developer toolkit on Plus ($499/month)
Where S Loyalty still wins
Rivo counts every Shopify order toward the bill, including orders with no loyalty activity. Between 1,000 and 2,500 orders, Scale costs $169 to $469/month. The Rivo listing caps Scale at $499, but Rivo’s website lists only a custom plan above 2,500 orders, so confirm the price before you commit.
Pricing:
- Free: $0/month for 200 orders, no overage
- Essential: $15/month for 500 orders, no overage
- Scale: $49/month for 400 orders, then $20 per 100, capped at $499/month on the listing
- Plus: $499/month for up to 2,500 orders
- Custom: quote
Best for: DTC brands on Klaviyo, Attentive or Postscript at 400 to 1,000 orders a month, where Scale costs $49 to $169.
7. Otter: Best for every feature on a $15 plan
Rating: 4.6 (22 reviews) | Price: $0 to $15/month, plus overage | Free trial: None (free plan)
Otter is a low-cost option for online-only stores that want VIP tiers and referrals without paying for a larger loyalty suite. VIP tiers, referrals and memberships are on both plans. Scaler costs $15/month for 300 orders and then $5 per 100, which comes to $50/month at 1,000 orders.
Otter was called Super Rewards & Loyalty and changed owners in May 2025. It has 22 reviews, so its record under the current team is short.
Why choose Otter over S Loyalty:
- VIP tiers, referrals, memberships and bonus events on every plan
- $50/month at 1,000 orders and $100/month at 2,000
- The programme keeps running past 300 orders, at $5 per 100
- 12 storefront languages
- Klaviyo and Judge.me integrations
Where S Loyalty still wins
Otter has no Shopify POS feature, even though the listing ticks POS rewards. Support is by email only, five days a week, with a reply within one business day. S Loyalty has 235 reviews and a record going back to 2012.
Pricing:
- Starter: $0/month for 100 orders, then $10 per 100
- Scaler: $15/month for 300 orders, then $5 per 100
A partial block of 100 orders is billed in full.
Best for: Online-only stores under 2,000 orders a month that want VIP tiers and memberships for $100/month or less.
What does each alternative cost as you grow?
Froonze costs the least at every volume, from $10/month at 500 orders to $60/month with no limit. S Loyalty’s $119.99 at 500 orders sits close to BON’s $129, but BON’s price includes VIP tiers and holds at any volume, while S Loyalty moves to a custom quote above 1,000 orders.
The table shows the cheapest plan with VIP tiers at each volume, overage included. S Loyalty has no VIP tiers, so its row shows the plan that fits.
| App | 500 orders | 1,000 orders | 2,000 orders | 5,000 orders | 10,000 orders |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Love Loyalty | $79 | $79 | $79 | $399 | $399 |
| BON | $129 | $129 | $129 | $129 | $129 |
| Froonze | $10 | $30 | $60 | $60 | $60 |
| BLOY | $49 | $49 | $109 | Custom | Custom |
| CWILL | $69 | $99 | $169 | Custom | Custom |
| Rivo | $69 | $169 | $369 | $499 (listing cap) | $499 (listing cap) |
| Otter | $25 | $50 | $100 | $250 | $500 |
| S Loyalty (for reference) | $119.99 | $119.99 | Custom, from $199.99 | Custom | Custom |
Love Loyalty’s $79 holds from 500 to 2,000 orders. Above that, Plus at $399 costs less than Growth with overage, which reaches $529 at 5,000 orders. Otter stays under BON’s $129 until about 2,500 orders and passes it by 3,000. Outside the table, BON charges $50/month for product or collection points below Growth, Love Loyalty takes 1.8% of paid membership sales on Growth, and Froonze prices wishlist and reviews separately. On S Loyalty, referrals add the ReferralCandy bill.
Which alternatives keep your monthly bill predictable?
Yes. BON, Froonze and Love Loyalty Plus all have plans with no order limit and no overage. S Loyalty also charges no overage, but it stops the programme at the limit, while these plans keep running at the same price.
- BON Growth: $129/month, no order limit
- Froonze Unlimited: $60/month, no order limit
- Love Loyalty Plus: $399/month, no order limit
- Rivo Scale: $49/month plus $20 per 100, capped at $499/month on the listing
- BLOY, CWILL and Otter: a set price per 100 extra orders on every paid plan
Under 2,000 orders, an overage plan is often cheaper, because Love Loyalty Growth at $79 costs less than BON at $129. A fixed bill pays off once seasonal peaks push you past the orders your plan includes. At 3,000 orders, BON’s $129 is below Love Loyalty Growth with overage at $229.
How do you switch from S Loyalty?
Switching takes five steps, and the risk sits in moving point balances correctly.
- Export your members, purchase history and point balances from S Loyalty.
- Ask the new app what it imports (balances, tiers, referral history) and who does the import.
- Import the data, then check 10 to 20 customers’ balances against your export.
- Email members that the programme has moved and their points came with them.
- Uninstall S Loyalty and check your theme for leftover widget code.
Love Loyalty includes free migration on Growth and Plus. BLOY’s team moves balances, tiers and history for free on every plan. Froonze offers a self-serve import on every plan and support-assisted migration on Premium at $30/month.
The others leave more of the work with you. CWILL’s FAQ says loyalty data is moved manually, with help for complex moves. For BON, Rivo and Otter, ask support before the trial what they import and who does it. The guide to moving loyalty points between Shopify apps covers the export in more detail.
When should you choose a different alternative?
A few store setups can change the recommendation, even when your order volume points to one of the picks above.
- Seasonal stores: S Loyalty sets your band from a 12-month average, so a big season can hold you on a higher plan. BON at $129 or Froonze at $60 keeps the bill flat all year.
- Selling on BigCommerce too: S Loyalty runs on both platforms, which keeps one programme across them.
- Shopify Plus checkout redemption: BON includes it on every plan, Froonze on Unlimited ($60), BLOY on Unlimited ($129) and Love Loyalty on Plus ($399).
- Above 5,000 orders: Froonze stays at $60, BON at $129 and Love Loyalty Plus at $399, while BLOY and CWILL need a quote.
- Wholesale customers: Froonze excludes them by tag on Premium ($30), and BON on Growth ($129).
Which S Loyalty alternative should you choose?
For most S Loyalty users, I’d start with Love Loyalty. It fills the gaps that push merchants away, with VIP tiers, referrals and POS on one plan priced below S Loyalty Premium. For the smoothest move, I’d look at BLOY, because its team handles the migration on every plan. Shopify Plus stores should also check list of the top loyalty and rewards apps for Shopify Plus, since checkout redemption sits on a different plan in each app.
- Growing or omnichannel stores: Love Loyalty Growth at $79/month for 2,000 orders. You get VIP tiers, POS and wallet passes, but past 2,000 orders it’s $15 per 100 or Plus at $399.
- Stores on a tight budget: Froonze Advanced at $10/month or Premium at $30/month. VIP tiers and POS are included, but wishlist and reviews cost extra.
- Stores that want a fixed bill: BON Growth at $129/month with no order limit. The price never moves, but under 500 orders you’d pay less for VIP tiers elsewhere.
Before you switch, export your S Loyalty member data and confirm with the new app’s support who handles the import.
S Loyalty alternatives FAQs
What are the best S Loyalty alternatives?
The best S Loyalty alternatives are Love Loyalty, BON, Froonze, BLOY, CWILL, Rivo and Otter. Love Loyalty fits most growing stores, with VIP tiers, referrals and POS on its $79 Growth plan. BON suits stores that want a fixed $129 bill at any volume, and Froonze is the cheapest with VIP and POS at $10/month.
Does S Loyalty have VIP tiers?
No. S Loyalty doesn’t offer VIP tiers on any plan, and its referrals run through ReferralCandy instead of the app itself. Froonze has VIP tiers from $10/month, BLOY from $49, CWILL from $69 and Love Loyalty from $79, and all four include a referral programme.
Is S Loyalty free?
S Loyalty has a Free plan for up to 100 orders a month, with three fixed-amount rewards, a birthday bonus and five storefront languages. New stores with no more than 50 lifetime orders can use a Starter plan for up to 12 months. Above 100 orders, the cheapest plan that fits is Standard at $39.99/month for 200 orders.
Can I move my S Loyalty points to another loyalty app?
Yes. S Loyalty exports customer purchase and redemption history, and the new app imports balances from that data. BLOY’s team does the move for free on any plan, Love Loyalty includes free migration on Growth and Plus, and Froonze offers a self-serve import on every plan. Check a sample of balances before you tell members.
Which S Loyalty alternatives work with Shopify POS?
Love Loyalty, BON, Froonze, BLOY, CWILL and Rivo all support Shopify POS. Froonze and BLOY start POS at $10/month, Love Loyalty at $12, Rivo at $15, CWILL at $19 and BON at $29. Otter has no POS feature, so in-store shoppers can’t earn or redeem points with it.
What should I check before switching from S Loyalty?
Check how the new app counts orders, what happens when you pass a plan limit and which plan includes the features you need. Ask support who handles the import before the trial starts. Magicbean’s review study also suggests testing points, redemption and POS on a development store before going live.
Daniel Smith
Tracks the Shopify App Store so everyday merchants don't have to. Having personally vetted, audited, and reviewed hundreds of apps, he cuts through the marketing noise to recommend tools that actually drive revenue. He helps brands build the ultimate lean, high-performing tech stack.

