Skip to content

Loyalty & Rewards

7 Best CWILL Loyalty Alternatives for Shopify in 2027

CWILL Loyalty is cheap to start. For $19/month you get POS and multi-language support, which most apps charge more for. The cost jumps when you want VIP tiers, because they sit on the Pro plan at $169/month for 2,000 orders, and the self-serve plans stop at 3,000.

I compared seven CWILL Loyalty alternatives (the app was previously called Loloyal and then TrustWILL) to see what you gain by switching, especially around VIP pricing, order limits, API access and languages. Love Loyalty stands out for growing stores that need VIP tiers, memberships and B2B without paying CWILL’s Pro prices. But if you’re under 500 orders and don’t need VIP tiers, there’s little reason to leave CWILL yet.

What are the best CWILL Loyalty alternatives?

The right alternative depends on what CWILL is making expensive or limiting for your store. Here are the seven I’d shortlist based on the problem you’re trying to solve.

  • For VIP tiers plus memberships and B2B: Love Loyalty, at $79/month for 2,000 orders.
  • For the cheapest VIP tiers: Appstle Loyalty, at $30/month for 2,000 orders.
  • For more than 3,000 orders at a flat price: Froonze at $60/month or BON Loyalty at $129/month, both with no order limit.
  • For a migration done for you, with 20+ languages: BLOY.
  • Stay on CWILL if you’re under 500 orders and points, referrals and POS cover your program.

The table shows each app’s rating and paid price range on 12 November 2026. For the full field, see our list of the best Shopify loyalty apps.

AppRatingPriceBest for
Love Loyalty Program & Rewards5.0 (428 reviews)$12–$399/monthVIP, memberships and B2B for less than CWILL Pro
Appstle Loyalty Program Reward5.0 (1,482 reviews)$10–$300/monthThe cheapest VIP tiers
Froonze VIP Loyalty & Wishlist5.0 (274 reviews)$10–$60/month (Loyalty plugin)No order limit below CWILL’s Pro price
BON Loyalty Program & Rewards5.0 (1,987 reviews)$15–$129/month (Plus custom)A flat price past CWILL’s 3,000-order ceiling
BLOY Loyalty Points & Rewards5.0 (845 reviews)$10–$129/month (custom above 4,500 orders)20+ languages and a migration done for you
Toki Loyalty Program & Rewards4.9 (98 reviews)$0–$599/month, plus $0.15 per order above the planVIP tiers on a free plan
Joy Loyalty Program Rewards4.9 (1,789 reviews)$29–$499/month, plus overageCustom earning rules and social rewards
CWILL Loyalty & Referrals (for reference)4.9 (800 reviews)$19–$229/month (Enterprise custom)Small stores that want POS and 20 languages cheaply

Why Shopify merchants look for CWILL Loyalty alternatives

CWILL doesn’t appear to have a widespread reliability problem. Magicbean’s review study found just two one- and two-star reviews, both mentioning missing features or difficulty using the app. The bigger frustration is what happens when your loyalty program needs more room to grow.

  • VIP tiers cost more than they do elsewhere: VIP tiers, points expiry and the Klaviyo integration all start on Pro. Pro costs $69 for 500 orders, $169 for 2,000 and $229 for 3,000.
  • The self-serve plans stop at 3,000 orders: above that, every store moves to Enterprise on a custom quote. Checkout extensions and API access also sit on Enterprise only.
  • Going over your limit pauses the program: CWILL’s website says the program keeps running for 3 days past the limit. After that it pauses until the next billing cycle unless you upgrade or buy extra orders, at $20 per 100 on Essential or $15 per 100 on Pro. The listing doesn’t mention those rates.
  • No paid memberships, B2B tiers or wallet passes: none of CWILL’s plan cards includes them, Enterprise included.

So switching makes sense when you need VIP tiers at 1,000 orders or more, or when you’re close to 3,000 orders a month.

Otherwise, stay. CWILL supports 20 languages and includes POS on the $19 Essential plan. Pro adds receipt scanning, which very few loyalty apps offer, and the free plan connects to CWILL’s own reviews and helpdesk apps. It holds a 4.9 rating from 800 reviews and the Built for Shopify badge.

How did I pick these alternatives?

I focused on apps that solve at least one of CWILL’s biggest limitations. Some offer VIP tiers for less, while others let you grow beyond 3,000 orders without negotiating an Enterprise plan. I compared their pricing and listings against four things that matter when making that switch:

  • What the cheapest plan with VIP tiers costs at 500, 2,000 and 3,000 orders.
  • Whether a self-serve plan covers 5,000 orders or more.
  • Whether POS and multi-language support are on the same plan as VIP tiers.
  • Who moves your points and tiers, and whether it costs extra.

Magicbean’s review study recommends that you read past the headline price and check order limits and which features need a higher plan. That’s where CWILL and its alternatives differ most. The Shopify loyalty app pricing comparison covers the rest of the category.

Which CWILL Loyalty alternatives are worth switching to?

1. Love Loyalty: Best for VIP, memberships and B2B for less than CWILL Pro

Rating: 5.0 (428 reviews) | Price: Free, then $12–$399/month | Free trial: 14 days on paid plans

Love Loyalty is where I’d look first if VIP tiers are the reason you’re leaving. Its Growth plan costs $79/month for 2,000 orders, $90 less than CWILL Pro at the same volume. Growth also adds paid memberships, B2B loyalty by customer segment, bonus campaigns and Apple and Google Wallet passes.

Love Loyalty also has the Built for Shopify badge, with point redemption in the cart and translatable storefront widgets. Its review profile is encouraging too. Magicbean’s study found no one- or two-star reviews among 186 written reviews, and support was mentioned in 60.2%.

Why choose Love Loyalty over CWILL:

  • VIP tiers for $79 at 2,000 orders, against $169 on CWILL Pro.
  • Paid memberships with a 1.8% fee on Growth and 0.8% on Plus.
  • B2B loyalty and wallet passes, which CWILL doesn’t sell on any plan.
  • API access and checkout extensions on Plus at $399/month with no order limit. CWILL keeps both for Enterprise.
  • POS from $12/month and free migration on Growth and Plus.

Where CWILL still wins

At exactly 3,000 orders, both apps cost $229, so the saving disappears. CWILL also offers receipt scanning on Pro, which Love Loyalty doesn’t list, and its free plan covers 200 orders against Love Loyalty’s 150.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 150 orders
  • Professional: $12/month, 500 orders, no overage
  • Growth: $79/month, 2,000 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Plus: $399/month, no order limit

Best for: a store between 1,000 and 2,500 orders a month that wants VIP tiers and plans to sell a membership.

2. Appstle Loyalty: Best for the cheapest VIP tiers

Rating: 5.0 (1,482 reviews) | Price: Free, then $10–$300/month | Free trial: 14 days

If keeping VIP costs down is your main reason for leaving CWILL, Appstle deserves a close look. Its Business plan costs $30/month for 2,000 orders and includes VIP tiers, points expiry, store credit and free-product rewards. That’s $139 less than CWILL Pro at the same order volume.

Appstle comes from a vendor that also sells subscriptions and memberships apps. Magicbean’s study found support in 83.2% of 179 written Appstle reviews and no one- or two-star reviews. Its pricing also keeps going past CWILL’s ceiling, with Business Premium at $100 for 5,000 orders.

Why choose Appstle Loyalty over CWILL:

  • VIP tiers for $30 at 2,000 orders.
  • POS from the $10 Starter plan.
  • A published price up to 20,000 orders, with API access on the $300 Enterprise plan.
  • White-glove migration on every plan, including Free.

Where CWILL still wins

Appstle’s admin dashboard is in English only, while CWILL’s comes in 20 languages. CWILL also adds receipt scanning on Pro, and its free plan connects to CWILL’s reviews and helpdesk apps.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 250 orders
  • Starter: $10/month, 500 orders
  • Business: $30/month, 2,000 orders
  • Business Premium: $100/month, 5,000 orders, then $0.015 per order
  • Enterprise: $300/month, 20,000 orders, then $0.015 per order

Best for: a store under 2,000 orders a month that wants VIP tiers for the lowest price.

3. Froonze: Best for no order limit below CWILL’s Pro price

Rating: 5.0 (274 reviews) | Price: Free, then $10–$60/month (Loyalty plugin) | Free trial: 14 days on the whole app

If CWILL’s 3,000-order ceiling is becoming a problem, Froonze is worth considering. Its Loyalty Unlimited plan costs $60/month regardless of order volume, with a public API, QR cards for POS and a checkout extension for Shopify Plus stores. VIP tiers, referrals and POS start on the $10 Advanced plan.

Froonze began as a customer accounts app. Rewards land in native Shopify store credit, and wishlist, reviews and accounts are sold as separate plugins. In Magicbean’s study, Froonze had no one- or two-star reviews among 108 written reviews, and customisation came up in 38.0%.

Why choose Froonze over CWILL:

  • No order limit for $60/month, where CWILL needs a custom quote above 3,000.
  • VIP tiers from $10 at 500 orders.
  • A public API without an enterprise contract.

Where CWILL still wins

Froonze prices each plugin separately, so adding reviews or a wishlist raises the bill. CWILL’s free plan already connects to its own reviews app. Froonze’s admin also supports 6 languages, against CWILL’s 20.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 100 orders
  • Advanced: $10/month, 500 orders
  • Premium: $30/month, 1,000 orders
  • Unlimited: $60/month, no order limit

Best for: a store above 1,000 orders a month that wants a flat loyalty bill.

4. BON Loyalty: Best for a flat price past CWILL’s 3,000-order ceiling

Rating: 5.0 (1,987 reviews) | Price: Free, then $15–$129/month (Plus custom) | Free trial: 7 days

BON Loyalty is worth a look if you’ve outgrown CWILL’s self-serve plans but don’t want to negotiate a custom Enterprise price. Its Growth plan costs $129/month with no order limit or overage. It includes VIP tiers, B2B tiers, points on product pages and custom CSS.

POS and 250+ displayed languages start on BON’s $29 Basic plan. Magicbean’s study found support in 76.3% of 186 written BON reviews, with 3 one- and two-star reviews.

Why choose BON Loyalty over CWILL:

  • One published price at any order volume.
  • VIP and B2B tiers on the same $129 plan.
  • More displayed languages than CWILL, from $29.

Where CWILL still wins

At 500 orders, CWILL Pro gets you VIP tiers for $69, while BON needs Growth at $129. BON’s lower plans also charge $50/month for points on specific products and $10/month to exclude customers by tag.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 150 orders
  • Starter: $15/month, 300 orders
  • Basic: $29/month, 500 orders
  • Growth: $129/month, no order limit
  • Plus: custom quote

Best for: a store doing more than 3,000 orders a month that doesn’t want a custom contract.

5. BLOY: Best for keeping 20+ languages with a migration done for you

Rating: 5.0 (845 reviews) | Price: Free, then $10–$129/month (custom above 4,500 orders) | Free trial: 14 days

If you’re happy with CWILL’s language support but want cheaper VIP tiers, BLOY is one of the closest alternatives. It supports 20 languages, and its Growth plan starts at $49/month for 1,500 orders. You also get VIP tiers, points on product and cart pages, and multi-language translation.

BLOY’s team moves your point balances, VIP tiers and customer history at no cost, on any plan. BLOY doesn’t have the Built for Shopify badge. Magicbean’s study found no one- or two-star reviews among 184 written BLOY reviews.

Why choose BLOY over CWILL:

  • Free migration done by BLOY’s team.
  • VIP tiers and translation from $49/month.
  • API access and headless support on the $129 Unlimited plan for 3,000 orders.

Where CWILL still wins

BLOY moves every store to a custom quote above 4,500 orders, so it only pushes CWILL’s ceiling back a little. CWILL also has the Built for Shopify badge and receipt scanning, and BLOY has neither.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 200 orders
  • Launch: $10/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Growth: $49/month, 1,500 orders, then $12 per 100
  • Unlimited: $129/month, 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100
  • Custom: quote above 4,500 orders

Best for: a multilingual store under 3,000 orders a month that wants the move handled for it.

6. Toki: Best for VIP tiers on a free plan

Rating: 4.9 (98 reviews) | Price: Free, then $49–$599/month plus $0.15 per order above the plan | Free trial: 14 days on paid plans

Toki is an interesting option if you want VIP tiers without adding another monthly subscription. Its free plan covers up to 1,000 orders and includes VIP tiers, referrals, POS, store credit and analytics. Every storefront language is also available on every plan.

Toki has the Built for Shopify badge. Magicbean’s study read 49 written Toki reviews and found no one- or two-star reviews. The $49 plan adds paid memberships, wallet passes, gift cards and one program across several stores.

Why choose Toki over CWILL:

  • VIP tiers and POS for $0 up to 1,000 orders.
  • Any storefront language on every plan.
  • Paid memberships and wallet passes from $49/month.

Where CWILL still wins

Toki charges $0.15 for every order above the plan, so it climbs quickly. At 3,000 orders Toki costs $299 against CWILL’s $229, and at 5,000 it costs $599. Our Toki alternatives cover cheaper options once you pass the free allowance.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 1,000 orders, then $0.15 per order
  • Pay as you Go: $49/month, 1,000 orders, then $0.15 per order
  • Growth: $299/month, 3,000 orders, then $0.15 per order
  • Power: $599/month, 5,000 orders, then $0.15 per order

Best for: a store under 1,000 orders a month that wants VIP tiers without a paid plan.

7. Joy: Best for custom earning rules and social rewards

Rating: 4.9 (1,789 reviews) | Price: Free, then $29–$499/month plus overage | Free trial: 14 days (30 on Ultimate)

Joy makes sense if your loyalty program relies on more than purchases to keep customers engaged. Its Advanced plan costs $129/month for 2,000 orders and includes custom earning rules, x2 and x3 bonus campaigns, VIP and B2B tiers, memberships, POS and wallet passes. You can also reward customers automatically for Instagram comments and story mentions.

Joy is made by Avada. Support came up in 79.9% of written Joy reviews in Magicbean’s study. Of Joy’s 7 one- and two-star reviews, pricing, plans or billing was the most common complaint.

Why choose Joy over CWILL:

  • VIP tiers plus memberships, B2B and wallet passes for $129 at 2,000 orders.
  • A rule engine for weekend, holiday or minimum-spend bonuses.
  • Instagram comment and story rewards.
  • Free migration done by Joy’s team.

Where CWILL still wins

POS starts at $19 on CWILL and at $129 on Joy. At 3,000 orders, Joy Advanced comes to $229 with overage, the same as CWILL Pro. The BON Loyalty vs Joy Loyalty comparison shows how Joy’s overage compares with BON’s flat $129.

Pricing:

  • Starter: $0, 250 orders
  • Essential: $29/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Advanced: $129/month, 2,000 orders, then $10 per 100
  • Ultimate: $499/month, 7,000 orders, then $5 per 100

Best for: a store around 2,000 orders a month that runs Instagram campaigns.

What does each alternative cost as you grow?

The biggest price differences show up around 2,000 orders. Appstle is the cheapest option there, while Froonze becomes particularly attractive once you pass 3,000 orders. Here’s how the monthly costs compare, including overage charges.

The table uses each app’s cheapest plan with VIP tiers at that volume, including overage. I added a 3,000 column because it’s CWILL’s last self-serve tier.

App500 orders2,000 orders3,000 orders5,000 orders10,000 orders
Love Loyalty$79$79$229$399$399
Appstle Loyalty$30$30$100$100$175
Froonze$10$60$60$60$60
BON Loyalty$129$129$129$129$129
BLOY$49$109$129CustomCustom
Toki$0$150$299$599$1,349
Joy$129$129$229$429$649
CWILL (reference)$69$169$229CustomCustom

One thing stands out. CWILL becomes harder to justify as order volume grows, especially when Froonze stays at $60 and BON at $129 without an order limit. Love Loyalty and Joy also keep published pricing beyond CWILL’s self-serve ceiling.

Can you keep multi-language support when you leave CWILL?

Yes, with all seven. What changes is the plan you need for it. CWILL’s admin comes in 20 languages, and storefront translation starts on its $19 Essential plan.

Three alternatives translate the storefront for free. Appstle shows a multi-language storefront on every plan, Froonze includes multi-language text editing on its free plan, and Toki makes any storefront language available on every plan. Love Loyalty’s storefront widgets can be translated too.

The rest put it on a paid plan. BON Loyalty displays 250+ languages from its $29 Basic plan, Joy offers manual translation from $29 and automatic translation from $129, and BLOY adds translation on its $49 Growth plan. Only BLOY matches CWILL’s 20-language admin. Appstle’s admin is English only, and Froonze’s comes in 6 languages.

How do you switch from CWILL?

Moving away from CWILL takes a little more preparation because its loyalty data has to be transferred manually. You’ll need to move customer records, point balances and VIP tiers into the new app, then check that everything matches before switching off CWILL.

  1. Ask CWILL support what you can export on your plan, since custom data export is listed as an Enterprise feature.
  2. Set up earning rules, rewards and VIP tiers in the new app before importing anything.
  3. Import the file yourself, or send it to the new app’s team if it migrates for you.
  4. Compare a sample of customer balances and tiers in both apps.
  5. Move the storefront widgets over, then uninstall CWILL.

Most of the seven will do the import for you. BLOY and Joy migrate for free with their own teams, on any plan. Appstle includes white-glove migration on every plan, and Love Loyalty includes free migration on Growth and Plus.

Toki adds migration support on its $299 plan, and any Toki plan can import members and balances from a CSV. Froonze is self-serve, with assisted migration from its $30 Premium plan. BON Loyalty doesn’t publish its migration terms, so ask before you install. The guide to moving loyalty points between Shopify apps covers the export step.

Which situations change the pick?

Above 3,000 orders a month, compare a CWILL Enterprise quote with BON Loyalty ($129) and Froonze ($60) before you decide. Both publish a price with no order limit.

On CWILL’s free plan with fewer than 200 orders, Toki’s free plan adds VIP tiers and POS for up to 1,000 orders.

For a store that sells mostly in person, POS is cheaper elsewhere, at $10 on Appstle, Froonze and BLOY and $12 on Love Loyalty. Our list of loyalty apps for Shopify POS compares them.

If you rely on receipt scanning, staying on CWILL is likely the cheaper choice. Of the apps I researched, only LoyaltyLion also offers receipt upload, and it starts at $199/month.

Which CWILL Loyalty alternative should you choose?

The decision mostly comes down to how quickly your loyalty program is growing and which features you actually use. If VIP tiers are pushing up your CWILL bill or you’re approaching 3,000 orders, switching is worth considering. If you’re still below 500 orders and don’t need VIP tiers, CWILL remains a sensible option. For stores still on a free plan, the list of free Shopify loyalty apps compares what each one includes.

  • For VIP plus memberships and B2B: choose Love Loyalty. Growth costs $79/month for 2,000 orders and adds wallet passes CWILL doesn’t sell.
  • For the lowest VIP price: choose Appstle Loyalty at $30/month for 2,000 orders. Its admin is English only, but storefront translation is on every plan.
  • For more than 3,000 orders: choose BON Loyalty at $129/month with no order limit, or Froonze at $60 if you don’t mind paying for its other plugins separately.

Check your monthly order count in Shopify for the last three months, then match it to the cost table above. That number decides most of this.

FAQs

What are the best CWILL Loyalty alternatives?

The best CWILL Loyalty alternatives are Love Loyalty, Appstle Loyalty, Froonze, BON Loyalty, BLOY, Toki and Joy. Love Loyalty adds VIP tiers, memberships and B2B for $79/month at 2,000 orders. Appstle has VIP tiers for $30. BON Loyalty and Froonze keep a flat price past CWILL’s 3,000-order ceiling.

Is CWILL Loyalty free?

CWILL Loyalty has a free plan for up to 200 orders a month, with points, referrals, review rewards and custom CSS. It doesn’t include a loyalty page, POS or VIP tiers. Paid plans start at $19/month for 200 orders, and VIP tiers need Pro from $69/month. The free program stops once you pass 200 orders.

Is CWILL Loyalty the same as TrustWILL Loyalty or Loloyal?

Yes. CWILL Loyalty & Referrals launched as Loloyal, was later called TrustWILL Loyalty and now carries the CWILL name. It’s the same app from CWILL in Cary, North Carolina, and its App Store address still uses the loloyal handle.

What happens when you go over your CWILL order limit?

On a paid plan, CWILL keeps your program running for 3 days after you pass the limit. You can upgrade or buy extra orders, at $20 per 100 on Essential or $15 per 100 on Pro. If you don’t, the program pauses until your next billing cycle. On the free plan, the program becomes unavailable at 200 orders.

Which loyalty app supports the most languages?

For shoppers, BON Loyalty displays 250+ languages from its $29 Basic plan, and Toki makes any storefront language available on every plan. Appstle and Froonze also translate the storefront on their free plans. For the merchant admin, CWILL and BLOY list 20 languages each, more than most loyalty apps. Appstle’s admin is English only.

How do I move from CWILL to another loyalty app?

Ask CWILL support what you can export on your plan, because CWILL says loyalty data moves manually and lists custom data export under Enterprise. Then import members, point balances and VIP tiers into the new app. BLOY, Joy and Appstle migrate for free on any plan, and Love Loyalty does on Growth and Plus.

D
Written by

Daniel Smith

Tracks the Shopify App Store so everyday merchants don't have to. Having personally vetted, audited, and reviewed hundreds of apps, he cuts through the marketing noise to recommend tools that actually drive revenue. He helps brands build the ultimate lean, high-performing tech stack.