Skip to content

Loyalty & Rewards

7 Best Appstle Loyalty Alternatives for Shopify in 2027

Most Appstle Loyalty alternatives cost more than Appstle. Its Business plan includes VIP tiers and 2,000 orders for $30/month, so you rarely leave it to save money. You leave it for something it can’t do.

I compared seven Appstle Loyalty alternatives on paid memberships, subscription orders, other languages and the jump from $30 to $100, because those are the gaps merchants run into. For most stores, Love Loyalty is the closest fit, because it keeps memberships and VIP tiers in one app at $79/month. Under 2,000 orders with no gap to fix, stay put.

What are the best Appstle Loyalty alternatives?

Love Loyalty is the best Appstle Loyalty alternative for most stores, because it adds paid memberships and B2B programs to VIP tiers in one app. The right pick depends on which gap pushed you to look:

  • For paid memberships and VIP tiers in one app: Love Loyalty, at $79/month for 2,000 orders.
  • For a migration done for you: BLOY, which moves your points and VIP tiers for free on any plan.
  • For high volume on a budget: Froonze, with unlimited orders on its $60 Loyalty plan.
  • For other languages: CWILL Loyalty, with 20 languages and multi-language support from $19/month.
  • Stay on Appstle if you’re under 2,000 orders and calendar-year VIP tiers work for you.

The table shows each app’s rating and paid price range on 12 November 2026. For the wider field, see our list of the best Shopify loyalty apps.

AppRatingPriceBest for
Love Loyalty Program & Rewards5.0 (428 reviews)$12–$399/monthPaid memberships and cart redemption in one app
BLOY Loyalty Points & Rewards5.0 (845 reviews)$10–$129/month (custom above 4,500 orders)A migration done for you on any plan
BON Loyalty Program & Rewards5.0 (1,987 reviews)$15–$129/month (Plus custom)A flat $129 with no order limit
Joy Loyalty Program Rewards4.9 (1,789 reviews)$29–$499/monthCustom earning rules and paid memberships
Essent Loyalty Program Rewards5.0 (496 reviews)$10–$79/monthPaying only on loyalty-influenced orders
Froonze VIP Loyalty & Wishlist5.0 (274 reviews)$10–$60/month (Loyalty plugin)Unlimited orders for $60
CWILL Loyalty & Referrals4.9 (800 reviews)$19–$229/month (Enterprise custom)Stores that sell in more than one language
Appstle Loyalty Program Reward (for reference)5.0 (1,482 reviews)$10–$300/monthVIP tiers for $30 under 2,000 orders

Why Shopify merchants look for Appstle Loyalty alternatives

Appstle Loyalty is cheap and well liked. Magicbean’s review study found no one- or two-star reviews for it in the study window, and support came up in 83.2% of its written reviews. So the reasons to leave are gaps in what the plans cover, and support can’t fix those.

  • VIP tiers renew on a fixed calendar: Appstle renews VIP status on calendar-year or lifetime spend only, with no rolling window. Maison GLOWLY raised this in October 2026 and no longer recommends the app.
  • Points on subscription orders aren’t reliable: Solli’s Hundebedarf chose Appstle Loyalty to pair with Appstle Subscriptions, then found in July 2026 that subscribers couldn’t redeem points on subscription orders.
  • The step from $30 to $100 has nothing in between: Business covers 2,000 orders with no overage. At 2,001 orders you move to Business Premium at $100, more than triple the bill. BLOY, by comparison, charges $12 per 100 extra orders on its $49 plan.
  • Memberships, APIs and other languages sit outside the $30 plan: paid memberships are a separate Appstle app, APIs and webhooks start on Enterprise at $300, and the listing supports English only.

That leaves a fairly clear decision. If you’re under 2,000 orders and calendar-year VIP tiers work for your program, Appstle is still a sensible place to stay. Start comparing alternatives when one of those limitations gets in the way of how you want to run loyalty.

How did I pick these alternatives?

I picked apps that close a specific Appstle gap without throwing away the low price that made you choose Appstle. I checked each app’s listing and pricing page on 12 November 2026 and judged them on four things:

  • Whether it fixes memberships, subscription orders, languages or the $30 to $100 jump.
  • What its cheapest plan with VIP tiers costs at 2,000 and 5,000 orders.
  • Which plan unlocks Shopify POS and checkout redemption.
  • Who does the migration work, and what it costs.

For price across the whole category, see the Shopify loyalty app pricing comparison.

Which Appstle Loyalty alternatives are worth switching to?

These seven each fix a different Appstle gap. Each one is compared with Appstle on the same items.

1. Love Loyalty: Best for paid memberships and cart redemption in one app

Rating: 5.0 (428 reviews) | Price: $12–$399/month | Free trial: 14 days

Love Loyalty is the alternative I’d look at first when the gap is paid memberships or B2B pricing. Its Growth plan costs $79/month for 2,000 orders and puts memberships, B2B programs and VIP tiers in the same app. That’s $49 a month more than Appstle Business, so you’re paying for features you can’t get on Appstle’s loyalty plans.

One detail shoppers will notice is the cart redemption. They can use their points directly in the cart without opening another pop-up. That keeps rewards part of the normal checkout experience.

Why choose Love Loyalty over Appstle:

  • Paid memberships are on Growth with a 1.8% fee. Appstle sells memberships as a separate app.
  • B2B programs by customer segment and Apple and Google Wallet passes come with Growth.
  • Growth adds $15 per 100 orders above 2,000, so you don’t jump to a new plan at 2,001.
  • Plus costs $399 with no order limit and adds checkout extensions and API access.

Where Appstle still wins

Appstle includes VIP tiers at $30, against $79 on Love Loyalty, and Business Premium covers 5,000 orders for $100.

Pricing:

  • Free: 150 orders a month
  • Professional: $12/month, 500 orders
  • Growth: $79/month, 2,000 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Plus: $399/month, unlimited orders

Best for: Stores between 1,000 and 4,000 orders that want paid memberships and VIP tiers in one app for $79/month.

2. BLOY: Best for a migration done for you on any plan

Rating: 5.0 (845 reviews) | Price: $10–$129/month | Free trial: 14 days

BLOY is the easiest move off Appstle. Its team moves your point balances, VIP tiers and customer history from your current app for free, on any plan, including Free. You don’t rebuild the program, and you don’t pay for the move.

Growth costs $49/month for 1,500 orders with VIP tiers, multi-language support and points on product and cart pages, then $12 per 100 after that. At 2,000 orders that’s $109. BLOY launched in October 2024 and had no one- or two-star reviews in Magicbean’s study window.

Why choose BLOY over Appstle:

  • Free migration of point balances, VIP tiers and customer history, done by BLOY’s team.
  • Multi-language support in 20 languages from Growth. Appstle’s listing supports English only.
  • Overage keeps the app running past your plan’s cap, with no forced upgrade.
  • Shopify POS starts on the $10 Launch plan.

Where Appstle still wins

Appstle includes VIP tiers at $30, and BLOY’s start at $49. BLOY’s plan called Unlimited stops at 3,000 orders, and above 4,500 every store moves to a custom quote. Appstle is also Built for Shopify, and BLOY isn’t.

Pricing:

  • Free: 200 orders a month
  • Launch: $10/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Growth: $49/month, 1,500 orders, then $12 per 100
  • Unlimited: $129/month, 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100
  • Custom: above 4,500 orders

Best for: Stores under 3,000 orders that want their Appstle points and VIP tiers moved for free, with VIP tiers from $49/month.

3. BON Loyalty: Best for a flat $129 with no order limit

Rating: 5.0 (1,987 reviews) | Price: $15–$129/month (Plus custom) | Free trial: 7 days

BON Loyalty is worth considering when Appstle’s order limit starts dictating your monthly bill. Its Growth plan stays at $129/month whether you process 2,001 orders or 20,000, making costs easier to predict as your store grows. Appstle Business Premium adds $0.015 per order above 5,000, so BON costs less from about 7,000 orders.

BON includes VIP and B2B tiers on Growth, and Shopify Plus stores can redeem points at checkout on every plan. Magicbean’s study found none of BON’s 142 support mentions was a complaint.

Why choose BON Loyalty over Appstle:

  • No order limit on Growth, so the bill stays at $129 as you grow.
  • B2B tiers sit alongside VIP tiers on the same plan.
  • Checkout redemption for Shopify Plus stores on every plan, against $100 Business Premium on Appstle.
  • 24/7 chat and email support on every plan.

Where Appstle still wins

Below about 7,000 orders, Appstle costs less, at $30 for 2,000 orders and $100 for 5,000. BON’s VIP tiers also jump from nothing on the $29 Basic plan to $129 on Growth.

Pricing:

  • Free: 150 orders a month
  • Starter: $15/month, 300 orders
  • Basic: $29/month, 500 orders
  • Growth: $129/month, unlimited orders
  • Plus: custom quote

Best for: Stores above 7,000 orders a month that want VIP and B2B tiers for a fixed $129.

4. Joy: Best for custom earning rules and paid memberships

Rating: 4.9 (1,789 reviews) | Price: $29–$499/month | Free trial: 14 days

Joy is for the store that has outgrown Appstle’s settings more than its price. Advanced costs $129/month for 2,000 orders and includes a rule engine for custom earning rules, VIP and B2B tiers, paid memberships and Shopify POS.

Joy also rewards Instagram comments and story mentions on Advanced, and every paid plan comes with a full refund in the first 30 days. Magicbean’s study found support in 79.9% of Joy’s written reviews.

Why choose Joy over Appstle:

  • A rule engine for custom earning rules on Advanced.
  • Paid memberships and B2B tiers on the same $129 plan.
  • Free migration of points, tiers and reward history, done by Joy’s team.
  • Overage of $10 per 100 above 2,000 orders keeps the app running.

Where Appstle still wins

Joy’s VIP tiers and POS both need Advanced at $129, against $30 and $10 on Appstle. At 2,000 orders that’s $99 a month more. Joy also counts every Shopify order, including social, imported and manual ones.

Pricing:

  • Starter: free, 250 orders a month
  • Essential: $29/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Advanced: $129/month, 2,000 orders, then $10 per 100
  • Ultimate: $499/month, 7,000 orders, then $5 per 100
  • Custom: above 17,000 orders

Best for: Stores between 1,000 and 5,000 orders that want custom earning rules and paid memberships on one $129 plan.

5. Essent Loyalty: Best for paying only on loyalty-influenced orders

Rating: 5.0 (496 reviews) | Price: $10–$79/month | Free trial: 14 days

Essent Loyalty is the one app here that counts only loyalty-influenced orders, meaning repeat sales and referrals. Appstle counts every order in your store. So a store doing 3,000 orders a month, with only some of them from loyalty members, can sit on a lower Essent plan than its total volume suggests.

Essent launched in November 2024 from Essential Apps, a Lithuanian team with more than 15 Shopify apps, and its website calls it Essential Loyalty. The free plan includes a single VIP tier, Starter at $10 adds Shopify POS, and Growth at $79 covers up to 5,000 loyalty orders with unlimited VIP tiers. Magicbean’s study found 1 one- or two-star review for Essent in the window.

Why choose Essent Loyalty over Appstle:

  • Only loyalty-influenced orders count toward your plan.
  • One VIP tier on the free plan, and unlimited tiers on Growth at $79.
  • No per-order overage. A paid plan that hits its cap moves up to the next plan automatically.
  • 20 supported languages on the listing.

Where Appstle still wins

Essent’s store credit is still in beta, and points expiry starts on the $24 Essential plan. Above 5,000 loyalty orders, Essent doesn’t publish its price, while Appstle lists $300 for 20,000. Appstle also has two more years of track record.

Pricing:

  • Free: 250 loyalty orders a month
  • Starter: $10/month, 500 loyalty orders
  • Essential: $24/month, 1,500 loyalty orders
  • Growth: $79/month, up to 5,000 loyalty orders

Best for: Stores where loyalty drives a small share of sales that want to pay $10 to $79 on those orders alone.

6. Froonze: Best for unlimited orders for $60

Rating: 5.0 (274 reviews) | Price: $10–$60/month (Loyalty plugin) | Free trial: 14 days

Froonze costs less than Appstle once you pass 2,000 orders. Its Loyalty plugin costs $60/month with no order limit, against $100 on Appstle at 5,000 orders and $175 at 10,000. VIP tiers, referrals, points expiry and POS all start on the $10 Advanced plan.

Froonze is modular. Loyalty, wishlist, reviews and customer accounts are separate plugins, each with its own price. Its loyalty rewards use native Shopify store credit, and Magicbean’s study found no one- or two-star reviews for it among 108 written reviews.

Why choose Froonze over Appstle:

  • Unlimited orders on the $60 Unlimited plan.
  • VIP tiers, referrals, points expiry and POS from $10, against $30 for VIP tiers on Appstle.
  • Native Shopify store credit as a reward.
  • Wishlists with price-drop and restock alerts as an add-on plugin, from $10.

Where Appstle still wins

Froonze’s prices cover the Loyalty plugin only. Wishlist, Reviews and Accounts cost extra, and both of its low-star reviewers said they found those charges only after installing. Appstle includes 24/7 live chat on every plan, while Froonze offers limited chat and full email support.

Pricing (Loyalty plugin):

  • Free: 100 orders a month
  • Advanced: $10/month, 500 orders
  • Premium: $30/month, 1,000 orders
  • Unlimited: $60/month, unlimited orders

Best for: Stores above 2,000 orders that want VIP tiers and unlimited orders for $60/month.

7. CWILL Loyalty: Best for stores that sell in more than one language

Rating: 4.9 (800 reviews) | Price: $19–$229/month (Enterprise custom) | Free trial: 14 days

CWILL Loyalty is the pick when your store sells in more than one language. Its listing supports 20 languages, while Appstle’s supports English only, and multi-language support starts on the $19 Essential plan. BLOY and Essent also list 20 languages, but BLOY puts it on a $49 plan.

CWILL, formerly Loloyal, comes from a vendor that also sells product reviews and a helpdesk, and the free plan connects to both. VIP tiers start on Pro at $69/month for 500 orders. Magicbean’s study found 2 one- and two-star reviews for CWILL among 104 written reviews.

Why choose CWILL Loyalty over Appstle:

  • Multi-language support from $19/month, with 20 languages on the listing.
  • Shopify POS from the same $19 plan.
  • Receipt scanning on Pro, which Appstle doesn’t list.
  • A Seal Subscriptions integration on every plan.

Where Appstle still wins

VIP tiers cost $69 on CWILL Pro against $30 on Appstle, and 2,000 orders on Pro cost $169. Above 3,000 orders, CWILL moves you to a custom Enterprise quote. Checkout extensions and API access also need Enterprise.

Pricing:

  • Free: 200 orders a month
  • Essential: $19/month for 200 orders or $29 for 500, then $20 per 100
  • Pro: $69/month for 500 orders, up to $229 for 3,000, then $15 per 100
  • Enterprise: custom quote

Best for: Stores under 3,000 orders that sell in several languages and want POS and translations from $19/month.

What does each alternative cost as you grow?

Up to 2,000 orders, Appstle’s $30 Business plan is hard to beat. Past that, Froonze’s $60 Unlimited plan costs less than anything here, Appstle included, and BON Loyalty’s flat $129 undercuts Appstle from about 7,000 orders.

Each cell shows the monthly bill on the cheapest plan that includes VIP tiers at that volume, overage included.

App500 orders2,000 orders5,000 orders10,000 orders
Love Loyalty$79 (Growth)$79 (Growth)$399 (Plus)$399 (Plus)
BLOY$49 (Growth)$109 (Growth)CustomCustom
BON Loyalty$129 (Growth)$129 (Growth)$129 (Growth)$129 (Growth)
Joy$129 (Advanced)$129 (Advanced)$429 (Advanced)$649 (Ultimate)
Essent Loyalty$10 (Starter, one tier)$79 (Growth)$79 (Growth)Not published
Froonze$10 (Advanced)$60 (Unlimited)$60 (Unlimited)$60 (Unlimited)
CWILL Loyalty$69 (Pro)$169 (Pro)CustomCustom
Appstle Loyalty (for reference)$30 (Business)$30 (Business)$100 (Business Premium)$175 (Business Premium)

Essent counts loyalty-influenced orders only, so its columns describe loyalty orders. A store doing 5,000 orders in total may only need its $10 or $24 plan.

The $30 VIP plan is the thing most Appstle users worry about losing. Only two apps here keep VIP tiers at $30 or less. Froonze includes them on its $10 Advanced plan up to 500 orders, and Essent’s free and $10 plans include one VIP tier. Every other app charges more for its first plan with VIP tiers, from $49 on BLOY to $129 on BON and Joy. Our guide to loyalty apps with VIP tiers compares them on tier features too.

Can you keep points on Appstle subscription orders?

I couldn’t confirm that any of these seven apps awards or redeems points on Appstle Subscriptions orders. None of them names Appstle Subscriptions in its integrations.

An integration listing alone doesn’t tell you whether recurring orders earn and redeem points correctly. Appstle’s own pairing has a reported gap. Appstle Loyalty lists Appstle Subscriptions as an integration, but Solli’s Hundebedarf reported in July 2026 that subscribers couldn’t redeem points on subscription orders.

Two alternatives do name other subscription apps. Love Loyalty works with Recharge, and CWILL Loyalty works with Seal Subscriptions on every plan. If subscriptions are a big part of your revenue, place a test subscription order during the trial and check that points arrive and redeem. Magicbean’s list of loyalty apps for subscription brands covers this in more detail.

Can you run paid memberships without a second app?

Yes, with two of these alternatives. Appstle’s loyalty plans don’t include paid memberships, because Appstle sells them as a separate Memberships app with its own bill.

Love Loyalty includes paid memberships on Growth at $79/month, with a 1.8% fee on membership sales (0.8% on Plus). Joy includes them on Advanced at $129/month. Either way, members, points and VIP tiers live in one app and one customer record.

The other five apps don’t include paid memberships on any published plan, so they’d leave you running a second app, just as Appstle does.

How do you switch from Appstle Loyalty?

You switch from Appstle in five steps, and most of the risk sits in the first two:

  1. Export your customers, point balances and VIP tiers from Appstle. Data exports are on every Appstle plan, including Free.
  2. Ask the new app what it imports, and how it handles VIP status earned under Appstle’s calendar-year rules.
  3. Install the new app, run the import and check 20 customers’ balances against Appstle by hand.
  4. Email your members that their points have moved, before you swap the widget on your store.
  5. Uninstall Appstle, then check your theme for leftover blocks and styles.

Three of the alternatives do the move for you. BLOY’s team moves point balances, VIP tiers and customer history for free on any plan, Joy’s team migrates points, tiers and reward history for free, and Love Loyalty includes free migration on Growth and Plus.

The others leave more of the work with you. Froonze offers self-serve migration on every plan and support-assisted migration from its $30 Premium plan. CWILL moves loyalty data manually, with team help for complex moves. BON Loyalty and Essent don’t say on their pricing pages what they import, so ask support before the trial. The guide to moving loyalty points between Shopify apps covers the export in detail.

Which situations change the pick?

The picks above assume one Shopify store between 500 and 5,000 orders a month, mostly in English. These cases change the answer:

  • Selling in several languages: Appstle’s listing supports English only. CWILL, BLOY and Essent each list 20 languages.
  • Loyalty is a small share of sales: Essent counts only loyalty-influenced orders, so a large store can stay on its $10 or $24 plan.
  • Checkout redemption on Shopify Plus: Appstle needs Business Premium at $100, BLOY needs Unlimited at $129, and BON includes it on every plan.
  • You need API access: Appstle starts it at $300, BLOY at $129 and Froonze at $60.

Which Appstle Loyalty alternative should you choose?

The decision comes down to the problem you need to solve. I’d narrow the shortlist to these three situations.

  • Need paid memberships or B2B programs: Love Loyalty on Growth at $79/month keeps both in the same app as points and VIP tiers. You pay $49 a month more than Appstle Business for it.
  • Past 2,000 orders on a budget: Froonze’s Loyalty plugin at $60/month has no order limit. Wishlist and reviews plugins cost extra.
  • Selling in several languages: CWILL Loyalty from $19/month, with VIP tiers at $69 on Pro.

Before you switch, export your Appstle data and ask the new app in writing what it imports and how it maps your VIP tiers.

Appstle Loyalty alternatives FAQs

What are the best Appstle Loyalty alternatives?

The best Appstle Loyalty alternatives are Love Loyalty, BLOY, BON Loyalty, Joy, Essent, Froonze and CWILL Loyalty. Love Loyalty suits stores that want paid memberships alongside VIP tiers, at $79/month. Froonze suits stores past 2,000 orders, with unlimited orders for $60/month.

Is Appstle Loyalty free?

Appstle Loyalty has a free plan for up to 250 orders a month. It includes points, referrals, loyalty pages and 24/7 live chat. Shopify POS starts on the $10 Starter plan, and VIP tiers, points expiry and store credit start on Business at $30/month.

Does Appstle Loyalty work with Appstle Subscriptions?

Appstle Loyalty lists Appstle Subscriptions as an integration, but one merchant reported in July 2026 that subscribers couldn’t redeem points on subscription orders. Before you rely on it, place a test subscription order and check that points are earned and redeemed.

Can I move my Appstle points to another loyalty app?

Yes, Appstle includes data exports on every plan. BLOY’s team moves points and VIP tiers for free on any plan, Joy migrates points and tiers for free, and Love Loyalty includes free migration on Growth and Plus. Check 20 customers’ balances by hand after the import.

Which Appstle Loyalty alternative is cheapest at high volume?

Froonze is the cheapest Appstle alternative at high volume, with unlimited orders on its $60 Loyalty plan. BON Loyalty also has no order limit, at $129/month. BLOY and CWILL Loyalty stop earlier, with custom quotes above 4,500 and 3,000 orders.

What should I check before leaving Appstle Loyalty?

Check which Appstle gap you’re fixing, and confirm the new app’s plan covers it at your real order volume. Then export your data, ask how VIP tiers will map, and test a full earn-and-redeem cycle during the trial before you uninstall Appstle.

D
Written by

Daniel Smith

Tracks the Shopify App Store so everyday merchants don't have to. Having personally vetted, audited, and reviewed hundreds of apps, he cuts through the marketing noise to recommend tools that actually drive revenue. He helps brands build the ultimate lean, high-performing tech stack.