Skip to content

Loyalty & Rewards

7 Best Essent Loyalty Alternatives for Shopify in 2027

Essent Loyalty alternatives almost always cost more than Essent. Its Growth plan caps the bill at $79/month for up to 5,000 loyalty orders, and it only counts orders that loyalty influenced. Very few apps price that way.

I compared seven Essent Loyalty alternatives on what sits above that ceiling: paid memberships, B2B tiers, wallet passes, API access and a published price past 5,000 orders. For most growing stores, Love Loyalty is the closest step up, because it adds memberships, B2B and wallet passes for the same $79/month. With a simple points program under 5,000 loyalty orders, Essent is still the better deal.

What are the best Essent Loyalty alternatives?

The seven apps below solve different problems. Some give you more loyalty features, while others make it easier to control costs as your store grows.

  • For memberships, B2B and wallet passes: Love Loyalty, at $79/month for 2,000 orders.
  • For VIP tiers on a free plan: Toki, free up to 1,000 orders a month.
  • For a published price past 5,000 orders: BON Loyalty, with a flat $129 and no order limit.
  • For the lowest bill at high volume: Froonze, at $60/month with no order limit.
  • Stay on Essent if you’re under 5,000 loyalty orders and points and VIP tiers cover what you run.

The table shows each app’s rating and paid price range on 12 November 2026. For the wider field, see our list of the best Shopify loyalty apps.

AppRatingPriceBest for
Love Loyalty Program & Rewards5.0 (428 reviews)$12–$399/monthMemberships, B2B and wallet passes Essent doesn’t have
Toki Loyalty Program & Rewards4.9 (98 reviews)$0–$599/month, plus $0.15 per order above the planKeeping VIP tiers on a free plan
BON Loyalty Program & Rewards5.0 (1,987 reviews)$15–$129/month (Plus custom)A published flat price past 5,000 orders
Appstle Loyalty Program Reward5.0 (1,482 reviews)$10–$300/monthA full store credit program and API access
Froonze VIP Loyalty & Wishlist5.0 (274 reviews)$10–$60/month (Loyalty plugin)Unlimited orders below Essent’s price
Joy Loyalty Program Rewards4.9 (1,789 reviews)$29–$499/monthCustom earning rules and social rewards
BLOY Loyalty Points & Rewards5.0 (845 reviews)$10–$129/month (custom above 4,500 orders)A migration done for you
Essent Loyalty Program Rewards (for reference)5.0 (496 reviews)$10–$79/monthSimple programs under 5,000 loyalty orders

Why Shopify merchants look for Essent Loyalty alternatives

Essent is cheap on purpose. Its website says “$79 is the ceiling”, and Magicbean’s review study found just 1 one- or two-star review for it, with setup (29.7%) and support (29.0%) the themes merchants mention most. The reasons to leave come from where that ceiling sits.

  • The ceiling stops at 5,000 loyalty orders: Growth covers up to 5,000. Above that, Essent says it costs more but doesn’t publish the price, even though its website still calls the plan unlimited.
  • The feature list ends early: none of Essent’s plans includes paid memberships, B2B tiers, wallet passes or an API. Analytics and unlimited VIP tiers both wait for the $79 plan.
  • Store credit is still in beta: it sits on the $24 Essential plan, and Essent labels it beta on its website. Points expiry starts on that plan too.
  • No multi-currency loyalty: Myeomi, a Polish store, raised this in January 2026, while still calling Essent better than the “overpriced alternatives”.

That gives you a simple test. Leave when you need one of those features or expect to pass 5,000 loyalty orders a month. Otherwise, Essent still covers the basics well. Its free plan includes one VIP tier, POS starts at $10, and paid plans move up automatically at the cap without per-order overage. It has a 5.0 rating from 496 reviews.

How did I pick these alternatives?

I picked apps that add what Essent’s plans leave out, without losing sight of Essent’s low price. I checked each app’s listing and pricing page and judged them on four things:

  • Whether it adds memberships, B2B, wallet passes, API access or a published price past 5,000 orders.
  • What its cheapest plan with VIP tiers costs at 2,000 and 5,000 orders.
  • How it counts orders, since Essent counts loyalty orders only.
  • Who does the migration work, and what it costs.

For price across the whole category, see the Shopify loyalty app pricing comparison.

Which Essent Loyalty alternatives are worth switching to?

1. Love Loyalty: Best for memberships, B2B and wallet passes Essent doesn’t have

Rating: 5.0 (428 reviews) | Price: Free, then $12–$399/month | Free trial: 14 days on paid plans

Love Loyalty suits a growing store that wants more than points and tiers without paying much more. Its Growth plan costs $79/month for 2,000 orders, the same price as Essent Growth. For that money you get paid memberships, B2B loyalty by customer segment, bonus campaigns and Apple and Google Wallet passes, none of which Essent sells on any plan.

It’s a Built for Shopify app, and shoppers redeem points straight in the cart. In the results by app, Love Loyalty had no one- or two-star reviews among 186 written reviews, and support came up in 60.2% of them.

Why choose Love Loyalty over Essent:

  • Paid memberships, monthly or yearly, with a 1.8% fee on Growth and 0.8% on Plus.
  • B2B loyalty programs and customer segments on the $79 plan.
  • Apple and Google Wallet passes for shoppers who buy in store.
  • Checkout extensions and API access on Plus at $399/month with no order limit.
  • Free migration on Growth and Plus.

Where Essent still wins

Love Loyalty counts every order, while Essent counts loyalty orders only. A store with 5,000 orders a month pays $399 on Love Loyalty Plus and $79 on Essent Growth. VIP tiers also start at $79 on Love Loyalty, while Essent includes one tier on its free plan.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 150 orders
  • Professional: $12/month, 500 orders, no overage
  • Growth: $79/month, 2,000 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Plus: $399/month, no order limit

Best for: a store between 500 and 2,000 orders a month that wants to sell a paid membership or run B2B tiers next to its points program.

2. Toki: Best for keeping VIP tiers on a free plan

Rating: 4.9 (98 reviews) | Price: Free, then $49–$599/month plus $0.15 per order above the plan | Free trial: 14 days on paid plans

Toki is the one app here where VIP tiers cost nothing. Its free plan covers 1,000 orders a month with advanced VIP tiers, referrals, store credit or cashback, POS and analytics. Essent’s free plan stops at 250 loyalty orders and one VIP tier.

Toki has the Built for Shopify badge. Magicbean’s study read 49 written Toki reviews and found no one- or two-star reviews, with support mentioned in 69.4%. The $49 plan adds wallet passes, paid memberships, gift cards and one program across several stores.

Why choose Toki over Essent:

  • VIP tiers, POS and store credit on a free plan up to 1,000 orders.
  • Paid memberships and wallet passes from $49/month.
  • One loyalty program across multiple stores on the $49 plan.
  • Every storefront language on every plan.

Where Essent still wins

Toki charges $0.15 for every order above the plan, and it counts all orders. At 2,000 orders the free plan costs $150, and at 5,000 Toki Power costs $599. Essent covers the same 5,000 loyalty orders for $79.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 1,000 orders, then $0.15 per order
  • Pay as you Go: $49/month, 1,000 orders, then $0.15 per order
  • Growth: $299/month, 3,000 orders, then $0.15 per order
  • Power: $599/month, 5,000 orders, then $0.15 per order

Best for: a store under 1,000 orders a month that wants VIP tiers without paying for them.

3. BON Loyalty: Best for a published flat price past 5,000 orders

Rating: 5.0 (1,987 reviews) | Price: Free, then $15–$129/month (Plus custom) | Free trial: 7 days

BON Loyalty fits the store that’s about to pass Essent’s 5,000-order ceiling. Its Growth plan costs $129/month with no order limit and no overage, so the price is the same at 6,000 orders as at 60,000. Essent doesn’t publish what it charges past 5,000.

Growth includes VIP tiers, B2B tiers, points on product pages and custom CSS. In Magicbean’s study, support was the most-mentioned theme for BON at 76.3%, with 3 one- and two-star reviews among 186 written reviews.

Why choose BON Loyalty over Essent:

  • A published $129 price with no order limit.
  • VIP and B2B tiers on the same plan.
  • POS earn and redeem from the $29 Basic plan.
  • 250+ displayed languages from Basic.

Where Essent still wins

BON’s plans below Growth charge add-ons that Essent doesn’t: $50/month for points on specific products or collections, and $10/month to exclude customers by tag. API access sits on the custom Plus plan only.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 150 orders
  • Starter: $15/month, 300 orders
  • Basic: $29/month, 500 orders
  • Growth: $129/month, no order limit
  • Plus: custom quote

Best for: a store doing more than 5,000 orders a month that wants a fixed bill.

4. Appstle Loyalty: Best for a full store credit program and API access

Rating: 5.0 (1,482 reviews) | Price: Free, then $10–$300/month | Free trial: 14 days

Appstle Loyalty makes sense when store credit matters to your program. Store credit is a full feature on the Business plan at $30/month for 2,000 orders, along with VIP tiers, points expiry and free-product rewards. On Essent, store credit is still labelled beta.

Support also comes up frequently in Appstle reviews. Magicbean’s study found it mentioned in 83.2% of written reviews, with no one- or two-star reviews. Appstle also offers 24/7 live chat on every plan. API access and webhooks are reserved for Enterprise at $300/month for 20,000 orders.

Why choose Appstle Loyalty over Essent:

  • Store credit as a finished feature from $30/month.
  • APIs and webhooks on the $300 Enterprise plan.
  • White-glove migration on every plan, including Free.
  • A published price up to 20,000 orders.

Where Essent still wins

Appstle’s listing supports English only, while Essent supports 20 languages. Essent also counts loyalty orders only, so a store with 6,000 total orders and few loyalty orders pays less on Essent.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 250 orders
  • Starter: $10/month, 500 orders
  • Business: $30/month, 2,000 orders
  • Business Premium: $100/month, 5,000 orders, then $0.015 per order
  • Enterprise: $300/month, 20,000 orders, then $0.015 per order

Best for: a store up to 2,000 orders a month that runs store credit as a main reward.

5. Froonze: Best for unlimited orders below Essent’s price

Rating: 5.0 (274 reviews) | Price: Free, then $10–$60/month (Loyalty plugin) | Free trial: 14 days on the whole app

Froonze is the simplest option when you want to remove the order cap without paying for an expensive plan. Its Loyalty Unlimited plan costs $60/month with no order limit, and it adds a public API, a checkout extension for Shopify Plus and QR cards for POS. That’s $19 less than Essent Growth, and it keeps working past 5,000 orders.

Froonze started as a customer accounts app and now sells wishlist, reviews and forms as separate plugins. Rewards go into native Shopify store credit. Magicbean’s study read 108 written Froonze reviews and found no one- or two-star reviews, with support in 81.5% and customisation in 38.0%.

Why choose Froonze over Essent:

  • No order limit for $60/month.
  • A public API on that same plan.
  • VIP tiers, referrals and POS from $10/month.
  • Points paid into native Shopify store credit.

Where Essent still wins

Froonze prices each plugin separately, so wishlist, reviews and accounts add to the bill. Its admin supports 6 languages, against Essent’s 20. Below 1,500 loyalty orders, Essent’s $24 plan is also cheaper than Froonze’s $60.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 100 orders
  • Advanced: $10/month, 500 orders
  • Premium: $30/month, 1,000 orders
  • Unlimited: $60/month, no order limit

Best for: a store above 2,000 orders a month that wants the lowest flat bill.

6. Joy: Best for custom earning rules and social rewards

Rating: 4.9 (1,789 reviews) | Price: Free, then $29–$499/month plus overage | Free trial: 14 days (30 on Ultimate)

Joy is for the store that wants to shape how points are earned. Its Advanced plan costs $129/month for 2,000 orders and adds a rule engine for custom earning, x2 and x3 bonus campaigns, VIP and B2B tiers, paid memberships, POS and wallet passes. It also rewards Instagram comments and story mentions automatically.

Joy is developed by Avada, a Shopify app studio. In Magicbean’s study, support was the most-mentioned theme at 79.9%. There were also 7 one- and two-star reviews, with pricing, plans and billing the most common complaints among them.

Why choose Joy over Essent:

  • A rule engine for bonuses on weekends, holidays or minimum order values.
  • Instagram comment and story rewards on Advanced.
  • Paid memberships, wallet passes and B2B tiers on one plan.
  • Free migration done by Joy’s team.

Where Essent still wins

Joy costs considerably more at volume. At 5,000 orders, Joy Advanced comes to $429 with overage, against $79 on Essent. API access and multi-store sit on Ultimate at $499. The BON Loyalty vs Joy Loyalty comparison shows how Joy’s overage compares with BON’s flat $129.

Pricing:

  • Starter: $0, 250 orders
  • Essential: $29/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Advanced: $129/month, 2,000 orders, then $10 per 100
  • Ultimate: $499/month, 7,000 orders, then $5 per 100

Best for: a store around 2,000 orders a month with an active Instagram following.

7. BLOY: Best for a migration done for you

Rating: 5.0 (845 reviews) | Price: Free, then $10–$129/month (custom above 4,500 orders) | Free trial: 14 days

BLOY is worth considering when you want the new app’s team to handle the migration. BLOY’s team moves points balances, VIP tiers and customer history from your current app at no cost, on any plan. Its Growth plan costs $49/month for 1,500 orders and includes VIP tiers, points on product and cart pages and 20+ languages.

BLOY doesn’t have the Built for Shopify badge. Magicbean’s study found no one- or two-star reviews among 184 written BLOY reviews, with support mentioned in 66.8%. POS and Shopify Flow start on the $10 Launch plan.

Why choose BLOY over Essent:

  • Free migration by BLOY’s team on every plan.
  • API access and headless support on the $129 Unlimited plan.
  • POS from $10/month.

Where Essent still wins

BLOY’s Unlimited plan has a 3,000-order limit, and above 4,500 orders every store moves to a custom quote. Essent publishes $79 for up to 5,000 loyalty orders. Our BLOY alternatives cover apps with a published price past that point.

Pricing:

  • Free: $0, 200 orders
  • Launch: $10/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Growth: $49/month, 1,500 orders, then $12 per 100
  • Unlimited: $129/month, 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100
  • Custom: quote above 4,500 orders

Best for: a store under 2,000 orders a month that wants the move handled for it.

What does each alternative cost as you grow?

The monthly price can look very different once each app starts counting every store order. Here’s how the bills compare as a store grows from 500 to 10,000 orders.

The table uses each app’s cheapest plan with VIP tiers at that volume, including overage. Every alternative counts all orders, while Essent counts loyalty orders only, so its row is a best case.

App500 orders2,000 orders5,000 orders10,000 orders
Love Loyalty$79$79$399$399
Toki$0$150$599$1,349
BON Loyalty$129$129$129$129
Appstle Loyalty$30$30$100$175
Froonze$10$60$60$60
Joy$129$129$429$649
BLOY$49$109CustomCustom
Essent (reference, loyalty orders)$10 (one tier)$79$79Not published

Toki stands out at 500 orders because its free plan includes VIP tiers. That changes quickly once a store passes its 1,000-order allowance, when the $0.15 per-order charge starts adding up. For a wider view of which apps gate VIP tiers where, see the list of loyalty apps with VIP tiers.

Can you keep paying only for loyalty orders when you leave Essent?

No. All seven alternatives count every order in your store, not just the ones loyalty influenced. That’s the biggest change to your bill when you switch.

Say your store takes 6,000 orders a month and 1,500 of them use loyalty. Essent bills you $24 on its Essential plan. Froonze would cost $60, Appstle $115, BON Loyalty $129, Love Loyalty $399, Joy $499 and Toki $749.

So check your loyalty-order count in Essent before you compare prices. If loyalty touches only a small share of your orders, the cheapest alternative can still cost more than double.

How do you switch from Essent?

You move members, point balances and VIP tiers into the new app, then turn Essent off once the numbers match. These five steps keep shoppers from losing points:

  1. Ask Essent support for a CSV export of members, point balances and tier status.
  2. Install the new app and set up your earning rules, rewards and tiers before you import.
  3. Import the CSV, or hand it to the new app’s team if it migrates for you.
  4. Check a sample of customer balances in both apps.
  5. Switch the storefront widgets over and uninstall Essent.

Who does the work depends on the app. BLOY and Joy migrate for free with their own teams, and Love Loyalty includes free migration on Growth and Plus. Appstle offers white-glove migration on every plan. Toki adds migration support on its $299 plan and white-glove help on $599.

Froonze is self-serve on every plan, with assisted migration from the $30 Premium plan. BON Loyalty doesn’t state its migration terms on its pricing page, so ask before you install. The guide to moving loyalty points between Shopify apps covers the export in more detail.

Which situations change the pick?

Above 5,000 loyalty orders a month, get Essent’s price in writing first. Its website doesn’t publish one, while BON Loyalty ($129) and Froonze ($60) do.

When loyalty touches only a small share of orders, stay on Essent. The loyalty-order billing usually beats any flat plan.

For multi-currency programs, confirm support with the new app before you switch, since that’s one of the gaps merchants raise with Essent.

Running several stores? Toki covers one program across multiple stores on its $49 plan.

Which Essent Loyalty alternative should you choose?

Start with two numbers. Check how many orders Essent counts as loyalty orders, then compare that with your total Shopify order count. The gap tells you how much an all-order pricing model could change your monthly bill.

Keep Essent when its features cover your program and your loyalty-order volume stays below 5,000. Choose Love Loyalty for memberships, B2B or wallet passes, BON for a published flat price at high volume, and Froonze for a $60 unlimited plan.

If free VIP tiers are your priority, Toki is the one to look at first. You can compare more options in our list of free Shopify loyalty apps.

Check both order counts before committing to a switch. They can make a bigger difference to your bill than the app’s starting price.

Essent Loyalty alternatives FAQs

What are the best Essent Loyalty alternatives?

The best Essent Loyalty alternatives are Love Loyalty, Toki, BON Loyalty, Appstle Loyalty, Froonze, Joy and BLOY. Love Loyalty adds paid memberships, B2B and wallet passes for $79/month. BON Loyalty and Froonze publish flat prices past 5,000 orders. Toki keeps VIP tiers on a free plan up to 1,000 orders.

Is Essent Loyalty free?

Essent Loyalty has a free plan for up to 250 loyalty orders a month, with one VIP tier. Paid plans cost $10/month for 500 loyalty orders, $24 for 1,500 and $79 for up to 5,000. Plans move up automatically at the cap, and Essent doesn’t charge per-order overage.

What happens above 5,000 orders on Essent?

Essent says stores above 5,000 loyalty orders a month pay more than $79, but it doesn’t publish the price. Ask Essent for a quote in writing. For a published figure, BON Loyalty costs $129/month and Froonze $60/month with no order limit, though both count all orders.

Is Essent Loyalty the same as Essential Loyalty?

Yes. Essent Loyalty Program Rewards is the Shopify App Store name, and the developer’s website calls it Essential Loyalty. Both refer to the same app from Essential Apps in Lithuania, with the same plans and the same $79 Growth ceiling.

Which loyalty app counts only loyalty orders like Essent?

None of the seven alternatives here counts only loyalty orders. Love Loyalty, Toki, BON Loyalty, Appstle, Froonze, Joy and BLOY all bill on every order in your store. YOYO bills on revenue its program generates, which is the closest model I found outside this list.

How do I move from Essent to another loyalty app?

Ask Essent support for a CSV export of members, point balances and tiers, then import it into the new app. BLOY and Joy migrate for free with their own teams, Appstle offers white-glove migration on every plan, and Love Loyalty includes free migration on Growth and Plus. Check a sample of balances before you uninstall Essent.

D
Written by

Daniel Smith

Tracks the Shopify App Store so everyday merchants don't have to. Having personally vetted, audited, and reviewed hundreds of apps, he cuts through the marketing noise to recommend tools that actually drive revenue. He helps brands build the ultimate lean, high-performing tech stack.