Skip to content

Loyalty & Rewards

7 Best Loyoly Alternatives for Shopify in 2027

Loyoly’s pricing starts to bite once a store passes 500 monthly orders. Lite costs $99 for those first 500 orders, then adds $0.30 for every extra order. At 2,000 orders, that brings the monthly bill to $549.

I looked at seven Shopify apps for the features Loyoly users may not want to lose, including VIP tiers, review and social rewards, wallet passes and migration help. Love Loyalty is the easiest place to start for a growing store. BON Loyalty is more appealing when a fixed monthly bill matters more than wallet passes or a dedicated account manager.

What are the best Loyoly alternatives?

Love Loyalty is the best Loyoly alternative for most stores, because its Growth plan includes VIP tiers, wallet passes and POS for $79 a month. The right pick changes with your order volume and with how much of your program runs on reviews and social posts.

  • 500 to 2,000 orders: Love Loyalty, for VIP tiers, wallet passes and POS at a relatively low monthly cost.
  • Review and Instagram-focused programs: Growave, for combining loyalty with photo reviews, video reviews and Instagram UGC.
  • High order volumes with a predictable bill: BON Loyalty, with its flat Growth plan.
  • Missions and games: Gameball, for streaks, spin-the-wheel campaigns and challenges.
  • French-speaking teams that value hands-on support: Staying with Loyoly may still make more sense, particularly at higher order volumes.

I checked every price below on 12 November 2026, and our list of the best Shopify loyalty apps covers the wider category.

AppRatingPriceBest for
Love Loyalty Program & Rewards5.0 (428 reviews)$12–$399/monthGrowing stores past 500 orders
Growave: Loyalty & Wishlist4.8 (1,287 reviews)$15–$999/monthKeeping UGC and review rewards
BON Loyalty Program & Rewards5.0 (1,987 reviews)$15–$129/month, Plus customA flat price at any volume
BLOY Loyalty Points & Rewards5.0 (845 reviews)$10–$129/month, then customThe lowest-cost VIP program
LoyaltyLion Loyalty & Rewards4.7 (550 reviews)$199–$549/month, then customA done-for-you setup
Gameball: AI Loyalty & Games4.7 (149 reviews)$34–$999/monthGamified missions and challenges
Yotpo: Loyalty Rewards Program4.7 (966 reviews)From $199/month, Premium customPairing loyalty with Yotpo Reviews
Loyoly – Loyalty and Referral (for reference)5.0 (118 reviews)$99–$999/monthFrench D2C brands using UGC missions

Why Shopify merchants look for Loyoly alternatives

Loyoly packs a lot into Lite, especially for European D2C brands. VIP tiers, points expiry, wallet passes and more than 40 missions are included at the entry level. The friction starts when order volume climbs. Its feature set stays attractive, but the bill rises with every extra order.

  • Every order past 500 adds to the bill. Lite and Premium both include 500 orders, then charge $0.30 per extra order. That puts Lite at $249 for 1,000 orders, $549 for 2,000 and $849 for 3,000. Love Loyalty’s Growth plan covers 2,000 orders for $79, and BON Loyalty’s Growth plan has no order limit at $129.
  • Premium costs $350 more for the same 500 orders. Store credit, cashback, checkout extensions and unlimited integrations sit on Premium at $449. Lite allows two integrations, and the account manager, custom CSS and points backdating are add-ons with no published price. Magicbean’s review study found that features behind a higher plan or order limits make up 25% of pricing complaint reasons among one- and two-star reviews.
  • The listing and the website quote different terms. The App Store plan cards say billed in euros, the website shows pounds and you pay in USD. The free plan appears only on the listing, and Enterprise is $999 on the listing but a custom price on the website. That makes a yearly budget harder to plan.

That pricing pressure starts early. Around 600 orders, Lite reaches $129, the same monthly price as BON Loyalty Growth, which has no order limit. At 3,500 orders, Loyoly’s Enterprise plan changes the calculation by capping the bill at $999.

There are still good reasons to stay. Loyoly is harder to replace if your team works in French, regularly uses its account managers or relies on its ready-made Google review mission. Above 3,500 orders, Enterprise may also be easier to justify. Its live chat is another advantage, with promised replies in under three minutes on every plan.

How did I pick these alternatives?

I used Loyoly Lite as the baseline. Each alternative had to preserve enough of its core features while offering a clearer cost as order volume grows. I looked for five things:

  • VIP tiers and points expiry at a published price, or a clear statement of what they cost
  • Points for reviews or social actions
  • Shopify POS support on at least one plan
  • A published monthly price, so the bill can be worked out before a trial
  • Help moving point balances and member history

The Shopify loyalty app pricing comparison covers costs for a wider set of apps.

Which Loyoly alternatives are worth switching to?

1. Love Loyalty: Best for growing stores past 500 orders

Rating: 5.0 (428 reviews) | Price: $12–$399/month | Free trial: 14 days

Love Loyalty suits Loyoly users who’ve grown past Lite’s 500 orders and want to keep VIP tiers, wallet passes and POS. At 2,000 orders a month, its Growth plan costs $79 and Loyoly Lite costs $549. From 4,200 orders, Plus at $399 with no order limit is cheaper than Growth plus overage.

Love Loyalty is a Built for Shopify app, launched in October 2024, that keeps loyalty data in Shopify metafields. Shoppers redeem points in the cart, and you can show points in 20+ storefront placements such as product pages. Magicbean’s review study found support in 60.2% of its written reviews, and none of its 200 sampled reviews were one or two stars.

Why choose Love Loyalty over Loyoly:

  • Growth covers 2,000 orders for $79, against $549 on Loyoly Lite.
  • Checkout extensions and API access sit on Plus at $399 with no order limit. Loyoly puts checkout extensions on Premium at $449 for 500 orders.
  • Paid memberships and B2B programs are on Growth, with a 1.8% fee on membership sales.
  • Storefront loyalty texts translate into French and German.
  • It has the Built for Shopify badge, which Loyoly doesn’t.

Where Loyoly still wins

Love Loyalty’s admin is in English only, while Loyoly’s comes in French, English, Spanish and German. VIP tiers start on Growth, so the $12 Professional plan has none, whereas Loyoly includes them on Lite. Loyoly also ships more than 40 ready-made missions, including Google reviews, where Love Loyalty uses custom earning rules you set up yourself.

Pricing:

  • Professional: $12/month for 500 orders, no overage (you upgrade above 500)
  • Growth: $79/month for 2,000 orders, then $15 per 100 orders
  • Plus: $399/month with no order limit

Paid memberships carry a 1.8% transaction fee on Growth and 0.8% on Plus.

Best for: A store at 500 to 4,000 orders that wants VIP tiers, wallet passes and POS on the $79 Growth plan.

2. Growave: Best for keeping UGC and review rewards

Rating: 4.8 (1,287 reviews) | Price: $15–$999/month | Free trial: 14 days

Growave is worth a look when reviews, customer photos and Instagram content matter as much as points. It puts loyalty, product reviews and wishlists in one app. At 2,000 orders, Growth plus overage costs $274, against $549 on Loyoly Lite, and that bill already covers your reviews app.

Growave’s admin comes in 16 languages, French and German included. Magicbean’s review study found support in 77.2% of its written reviews. The same study counted 8 one- and two-star reviews, mainly about bugs, support and charges after uninstalling.

Why choose Growave over Loyoly:

  • Photo reviews, review request emails and points for reviews start on Entry at $15.
  • Growth at $199 adds Instagram UGC, video reviews, AI review summaries and reviews in the Google Shopping feed.
  • Store credit online and in POS, plus Apple and Google Wallet passes, come with Growth. Loyoly keeps store credit on Premium at $449.
  • Unlimited costs $999 with no order limit, the same as Loyoly Enterprise, and adds reviews and wishlists.
  • A multi-language storefront is on every plan.

Where Loyoly still wins

VIP tiers, points expiry and a loyalty page all need Growave’s $199 Growth plan, while Loyoly includes them on Lite at $99. Growave’s record is less clean too, with 50 of its 1,287 reviews at three stars or lower against none for Loyoly. Overage also runs $10 to $20 per 100 orders, depending on the plan.

Pricing:

  • Entry: $15/month for 500 orders, then $20 per 100 orders
  • Growth: $199/month for 1,500 orders, then $15 per 100 orders
  • Plus: $499/month for 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100 orders
  • Unlimited: $999/month with no order limit

Best for: A brand at 1,000 to 3,000 orders that wants loyalty, photo and video reviews and Instagram UGC in one app from $199.

3. BON Loyalty: Best for a flat price at any volume

Rating: 5.0 (1,987 reviews) | Price: $15–$129/month, Plus custom | Free trial: 7 days

BON Loyalty is the straightforward pick when you want your monthly bill to stop following order volume. Its Growth plan costs $129 with no order limit and includes VIP tiers. At 5,000 orders, Loyoly charges $999 on Enterprise, so the monthly difference is $870.

BON is a Built for Shopify app from a Canadian team, and its admin comes in French, German and Spanish as well as English and Japanese. Magicbean’s review study found support in 76.3% of its written reviews, and none of its 142 support mentions were complaints. Switchers in the study named BON as the app they moved to 8 times, level with Love Loyalty.

Why choose BON Loyalty over Loyoly:

  • Growth costs $129 at any volume and adds VIP and B2B tiers.
  • POS earning and redemption start on Basic at $29.
  • The storefront displays in 250+ languages from Basic.
  • Points for social actions are on every plan, and points for reviews start on Starter at $15.
  • There are no contracts, setup fees or per-order charges.

Where Loyoly still wins

BON doesn’t list Apple or Google Wallet passes, which Loyoly includes in its plans. API access and an SDK sit on the custom Plus plan. BON’s support runs on chat and email, without the account manager and business reviews Loyoly offers on Premium.

Pricing:

  • Starter: $15/month for 300 orders
  • Basic: $29/month for 500 orders
  • Growth: $129/month with no order limit
  • Plus: custom quote

No plan charges overage, so you upgrade when you pass a limit. Below Growth, points for specific collections or products cost $50/month and excluding customers by tag costs $10/month.

Best for: A store above 2,000 orders that wants VIP tiers and POS at a fixed $129 a month.

4. BLOY: Best for the lowest-cost VIP program

Rating: 5.0 (845 reviews) | Price: $10–$129/month, then custom | Free trial: 14 days

BLOY makes the most sense when affordable VIP tiers matter more to you than a long list of built-in missions. Its Growth plan costs $49 for 1,500 orders, so a 1,000-order store pays $49 instead of $249 on Loyoly Lite. At 2,000 orders, Growth plus overage comes to $109.

BLOY is a Singapore-based app launched in October 2024, and its admin runs in 20 languages, French and German included. Its team moves point balances, VIP tiers and customer history from your current app for free on any plan. Magicbean’s review study counted no one- or two-star reviews for BLOY, and its 40 customization mentions had no complaints.

Why choose BLOY over Loyoly:

  • VIP tiers, entry rewards and custom perks start on Growth at $49.
  • POS, Shopify Flow and every integration start on Launch at $10, where Loyoly Lite allows two integrations.
  • BLOY’s team handles the migration at no cost.
  • Points show on product, cart and post-purchase pages from Growth.
  • Overage rates are published per plan, and you’re never moved up a plan automatically.

Where Loyoly still wins

BLOY has no published price above 4,500 orders, while Loyoly’s Enterprise is $999 with no order limit. Its plan called Unlimited includes 3,000 orders, then charges $10 per 100. BLOY also doesn’t list wallet passes, which Loyoly includes.

Pricing:

  • Launch: $10/month for 500 orders, then $15 per 100 orders
  • Growth: $49/month for 1,500 orders, then $12 per 100 orders
  • Unlimited: $129/month for 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100 orders
  • Custom: quote above 4,500 orders

Best for: A store at 500 to 3,000 orders that wants VIP tiers from $49 and a migration done by the app’s team.

5. LoyaltyLion: Best for a done-for-you setup

Rating: 4.7 (550 reviews) | Price: $199–$549/month, then custom | Free trial: 14 days

LoyaltyLion is for teams that would rather pay for hands-on setup than build the loyalty experience themselves. Classic builds your loyalty page and Klaviyo email flows and gives you an onboarding manager. At 2,000 orders, Classic costs $349, against $549 on Loyoly Lite, before you add VIP tiers.

LoyaltyLion is a London company, and every plan includes 8 pre-translated languages, with French, German, Spanish and Italian among them. Magicbean’s review study found setup in 48.6% of its written reviews, and setup help makes up 54% of its support praise. Pricing came up less often, but 44% of its 9 pricing mentions were complaints.

Why choose LoyaltyLion over Loyoly:

  • The loyalty page and Klaviyo flows are built for you on Classic.
  • API and headless API access are on every plan. Loyoly keeps its developer toolkit for Enterprise at $999.
  • Every plan connects to Claude, Shopify Sidekick and other AI assistants through MCP.
  • Advanced adds 130+ languages and POS across several locations.
  • Classic tops out at $549 for 4,000 orders, where Loyoly charges $999.

Where Loyoly still wins

VIP tiers are a paid add-on on Classic, priced by quote, while Loyoly includes them on Lite. The Loyalty Pass for Apple and Google Wallet is an add-on on every LoyaltyLion plan, and Classic covers POS at one location only. Above 4,000 orders, every plan is a custom quote.

Pricing:

  • Classic: $199/month for 500 orders, rising to $549/month for 4,000 orders
  • Advanced: custom quote
  • Plus: custom quote

VIP tiers, the Loyalty Pass and receipt upload are paid add-ons on Classic. LoyaltyLion lists no overage fee, but it reviews your plan when you pass the agreed volume by more than 25% over three months.

Best for: A brand at 500 to 4,000 orders that wants its loyalty page and Klaviyo flows built for it, on Classic from $199.

6. Gameball: Best for gamified missions and challenges

Rating: 4.7 (149 reviews) | Price: $34–$999/month | Free trial: 7 days

Gameball takes the missions idea in a more playful direction, with streaks, spins and challenges at the center. Gameball bills by monthly rewarded customers instead of orders. So a store with 2,000 orders but fewer than 1,000 rewarded customers a month fits the $159 Pro plan, against $549 on Loyoly Lite.

Gameball’s admin comes in 9 languages, French, German, Spanish and Arabic included. Streaks, spin the wheel, point multipliers and badges start on Starter, and leaderboards come with Guru. Magicbean’s review study sampled 16 Gameball reviews. Support came up in 10 of the 14 written ones, and 3 were one or two stars.

Why choose Gameball over Loyoly:

  • Streak, spin-the-wheel and point multiplier campaigns start on Starter at $34.
  • Billing counts rewarded customers, so orders without a reward don’t raise the bill.
  • Five VIP tiers, points expiry and rewards for reviews come with Starter, and Pro removes the tier limit.
  • RFM segments and checkout embeds are on Pro at $159.
  • Guru adds two AI loyalty experts that set up point economics and suggest campaigns.

Where Loyoly still wins

No source converts rewarded customers into orders, so it’s hard to predict which plan a busy store lands on. API access costs $199/month extra on Pro, Starter shows the storefront in 2 languages and Guru jumps to $999. Gameball also has 8 one-star reviews out of 149, mostly about setup errors and support, while Loyoly has none.

Pricing:

  • Starter: $34/month for 300 rewarded customers
  • Pro: $159/month for 1,000 rewarded customers
  • Guru: $999/month for 10,000 rewarded customers

No plan charges overage, so you upgrade when you pass a limit. Our list of gamified loyalty apps for Shopify covers other apps built around games.

Best for: A brand that wants streaks and challenges and rewards fewer than 1,000 customers a month, on Pro at $159.

7. Yotpo: Best for pairing loyalty with Yotpo Reviews

Rating: 4.7 (966 reviews) | Price: From $199/month, Premium custom | Free trial: none listed

Yotpo is easiest to justify when your reviews already live in its ecosystem. The Reviews and Loyalty bundle starts at $199 a month. On its own, Yotpo’s Pro plan costs $199 for 500 orders plus $0.20 per extra order, which comes to $499 at 2,000 orders against $549 on Loyoly Lite.

Yotpo’s loyalty app was called Swell Rewards before Yotpo bought it, and it also runs on BigCommerce, Adobe Commerce and WooCommerce. Magicbean’s review study found support in 86.3% of its written reviews and reliability in 35.3%, its second-highest theme. The study counted 10 one- and two-star reviews for Yotpo.

Why choose Yotpo over Loyoly:

  • Pro gives points for reviews, photo and video reviews, Instagram follows, Facebook shares and SMS sign-ups.
  • The bundle puts reviews and loyalty with one vendor from $199.
  • Shoppers redeem points at checkout on Pro.
  • Yotpo’s team migrates member data and point balances from your old app.
  • Enterprise runs one program across several brands and markets.

Where Loyoly still wins

VIP tiers, POS, free-product rewards and gift cards all sit on Premium, a custom quote, while Loyoly has VIP tiers and POS on Lite. Pro stops fitting at 2,500 orders, where you move to Premium. Yotpo’s low-star share is 8.1%, or 78 of 966 reviews, and our Yotpo Loyalty alternatives cover apps with VIP tiers at a published price.

Pricing:

  • Pro: $199/month for 500 orders, then $0.20 per order
  • Premium: custom quote
  • Enterprise: custom quote

The Reviews and Loyalty bundle also starts at $199/month.

Best for: A store under 2,500 orders that already uses Yotpo Reviews and wants review and social points on Pro from $199.

What does each alternative cost as you grow?

The cheapest option changes as your store grows. This table compares the lowest-priced plan with VIP tiers at each order volume, including overage charges.

App500 orders2,000 orders5,000 orders10,000 orders
Love Loyalty$79 (Growth)$79 (Growth)$399 (Plus)$399 (Plus)
Growave$199 (Growth)$274 (Growth)$699 (Plus)$999 (Unlimited)
BON Loyalty$129 (Growth)$129 (Growth)$129 (Growth)$129 (Growth)
BLOY$49 (Growth)$109 (Growth)CustomCustom
LoyaltyLion$199 + VIP add-on$349 + VIP add-onCustomCustom
GameballNot order-basedNot order-basedNot order-basedNot order-based
YotpoCustom (Premium)Custom (Premium)Custom (Premium)Custom (Premium)
Loyoly (for reference)$99 (Lite)$549 (Lite)$999 (Enterprise)$999 (Enterprise)

Gameball’s Starter ($34), Pro ($159) and Guru ($999) plans cover 300, 1,000 and 10,000 rewarded customers a month.

Loyoly Lite plus overage passes the $999 Enterprise price at 3,500 orders. So a Loyoly store between 2,000 and 3,500 orders pays more than any fully published price in the table. Love Loyalty’s Growth overage makes Plus the cheaper plan from 4,200 orders. Outside the table, Love Loyalty charges a 1.8% fee on paid memberships on Growth, Gameball adds $199/month for API access on Pro and LoyaltyLion prices its VIP add-on by quote.

Can you keep UGC and review rewards when you leave Loyoly?

You can keep most review and social rewards when moving away from Loyoly, although the available actions vary by app. Growave and Yotpo come closest to Loyoly’s mission list. Here’s where each one starts.

  • Love Loyalty: points for reviews, follows and shares through rewards for activities and custom earning rules on Growth, at $79
  • Growave: points for reviews from Entry at $15, plus Instagram UGC and video reviews on Growth at $199
  • BON Loyalty: social points on every plan, and review points from Starter at $15
  • BLOY: review rewards from Launch at $10
  • LoyaltyLion: points for reviews, social and custom activities on Classic at $199
  • Gameball: review rewards on Starter at $34, and custom action campaigns on Pro at $159
  • Yotpo: points for reviews, photo and video reviews and Instagram and Facebook actions on Pro at $199

The main feature to check before moving is Google reviews. None of the seven alternatives lists a dedicated Google review mission, so ask whether a custom earning rule can cover it before you switch.

How do you switch from Loyoly?

The actual switch is manageable. The part that deserves care is preserving point balances, VIP status and expiry dates.

  1. Export your members, point balances, VIP tiers and referral history from Loyoly. Ask Loyoly’s live chat for the export format first.
  2. Ask the new app which fields it imports, including tier status and points expiry dates.
  3. Import into the new app and spot-check accounts with large balances and top tiers before going live.
  4. Email members about the move, with their new balance and where to find the program.
  5. Uninstall Loyoly, then check your theme for leftover widgets, code and metafields.

BLOY’s team moves point balances, VIP tiers and customer history for free on any plan. Love Loyalty includes free migration on Growth and Plus, and Yotpo’s team migrates member data and point balances. LoyaltyLion helps import customer data once your account is set up, and Growave offers a CSV import or an assisted migration.

BON Loyalty and Gameball don’t describe their import process on their pricing pages, so ask support before the trial. Magicbean’s review study found 17 low-rated reviews about leaving an app or changing plans, with 4 about code or data left on the store and 4 about lost reviews or points. The guide to moving loyalty points between Shopify apps covers the export, and the explainer on loyalty data after you uninstall covers the clean-up.

When should you choose a different app?

A few specific needs can outweigh the order-volume calculation. These are worth considering before making the switch:

  • A team that works in French: Growave, BON Loyalty, BLOY and Gameball offer a French admin. Love Loyalty’s admin is English only.
  • Wallet passes for in-store shoppers: Love Loyalty and Growave include Apple and Google Wallet passes on Growth, at $79 and $199.
  • Redemption at checkout on Shopify Plus: BON Loyalty supports it on every plan, and BLOY on Unlimited at $129.
  • More than 5,000 orders: only BON Loyalty, Love Loyalty and Growave publish a price, at $129, $399 and $999.
  • Several brands on one program: LoyaltyLion’s Cross-Store Rewards add-on on Plus and Yotpo Enterprise cover this, both by quote.

Which Loyoly alternative should you choose?

Love Loyalty is my default pick, but the right move depends on what you’re least willing to give up. Some stores need better review tools, others want a predictable bill or a migration handled for them. These are the three alternatives I’d narrow it down to.

  • Growing stores at 500 to 4,000 orders: Love Loyalty on Growth at $79 for 2,000 orders, then $15 per 100. You give up a French admin and Loyoly’s Google review mission.
  • Brands built on reviews and Instagram posts: Growave on Growth at $199 for 1,500 orders, with photo and video reviews and Instagram UGC in the same app. At 500 orders, its VIP tiers cost $100 more than Loyoly Lite.
  • High-volume stores that want a fixed bill: BON Loyalty on Growth at $129 with no order limit. You lose wallet passes and Loyoly’s account manager.

Before you switch, ask Loyoly what its export includes and confirm the new app can import your tiers and expiry dates.

Loyoly alternatives FAQs

What are the best Loyoly alternatives?

The best Loyoly alternatives are Love Loyalty, Growave, BON Loyalty, BLOY, LoyaltyLion, Gameball and Yotpo. Love Loyalty fits most growing stores, with VIP tiers, wallet passes and POS on its $79 Growth plan for 2,000 orders. Growave suits review-led brands, and BON Loyalty suits high-volume stores at a flat $129.

How much does Loyoly cost?

Loyoly costs $99 a month on Lite and $449 on Premium, each for 500 orders, then $0.30 per extra order. Enterprise costs $999 with no order limit. That puts Lite at $549 for 2,000 orders. Loyoly’s App Store listing shows a free plan that its website doesn’t, so confirm the current plans in the app before you budget.

Which Loyoly alternatives work in French?

Growave, BON Loyalty, BLOY and Gameball offer a French admin, and LoyaltyLion includes French among its 8 pre-translated program languages. Love Loyalty translates its storefront loyalty texts into French and German, but its admin is English only. Loyoly still has the edge for teams that want French-speaking account managers.

Will a new loyalty app slow down my Shopify store?

A loyalty app adds scripts to your storefront, so test speed on a development store before you switch. Love Loyalty, Growave and BON Loyalty carry the Built for Shopify badge, which Shopify gives to apps that meet its performance and design standards. Loyoly, LoyaltyLion, BLOY, Gameball and Yotpo don’t have the badge.

Can I move my Loyoly points to another app?

Yes, but Loyoly first needs to export your members, point balances and VIP tiers. BLOY moves balances, tiers and history for free on any plan, Love Loyalty includes free migration on Growth and Plus, and Yotpo’s team migrates point balances. Spot-check imported accounts before you go live, then email members their new balance.

Is there a Loyoly alternative with no per-order fees?

BON Loyalty has no per-order fees on any plan, and its Growth plan costs $129 with no order limit. Love Loyalty Plus costs $399 and Growave Unlimited costs $999, both with no order limit. Love Loyalty’s Growth plan charges $15 per 100 orders above 2,000, and BLOY, Growave and Yotpo charge overage on their lower plans.

E
Written by

Emily Johnson

Writes clear, practical guides that help Shopify store owners make more money and save time. Instead of confusing technical jargon, she focuses on what actually matters to a business: how the right tools can boost sales, automate boring tasks, and make customers happier.