Skip to content

Loyalty & Rewards

Growave vs Love Loyalty: Honest Comparison [2027 Edition]

If you’re deciding between Growave vs Love Loyalty, you’re really deciding whether you want a bundle or a specialist. Growave sells loyalty, product reviews, and a wishlist as one subscription, and it’s been on the App Store since July 2014. Love Loyalty does loyalty and nothing else, and it launched in October 2024.

That difference matters most when you look at the loyalty apps already on your bill. If you’re replacing separate reviews and wishlist apps, Growave’s $199 plan may cost less overall. If those jobs are already covered, Love Loyalty is the cheaper way to run points, tiers, and referrals. Both carry the Built for Shopify badge, but the bigger decision is how much of your existing stack you want one app to handle.

Growave vs Love Loyalty: Our top pick

For loyalty on its own, Love Loyalty is the better buy for most Shopify stores. Growave wins when you’d otherwise pay for reviews and a wishlist separately, or when your storefront isn’t English-only.

Choose Growave: You’re still paying for a reviews app and a wishlist app, and you’d rather have one bill and one theme integration. It’s also the pick if you sell in a second language, need Instagram UGC or Google Shopping reviews, or want twelve years of dated merchant feedback before you commit.

Choose Love Loyalty: You already have reviews sorted and want the loyalty layer at the lowest published price. Tiers, paid memberships, B2B segments, and wallet passes all arrive at $79, against $199 to $499 on Growave, and paying annually takes 17% to 25% off.

Look beyond both: Both apps charge overage in blocks of 100 orders until their top plans. If you want unlimited orders on a flat bill well below $399, BON Loyalty offers that at $129.

What does each app offer?

Growave

Growave earns its place by removing apps rather than by being the best loyalty program on the shelf. One subscription runs points and rewards, product reviews with photo and attribute capture, and a wishlist, with Instagram UGC and Google Shopping reviews added on Growth. For a small team that would otherwise maintain three apps and three theme integrations, that consolidation is the product.

The loyalty side is solid rather than distinctive. Rewards, referrals with fraud protection, and on-site nudges start at $15. VIP tiers, store credit online and at POS, a custom loyalty page, points expiry, and wallet passes all wait for Growth at $199. Checkout extensions, the API and SDK, custom reward actions, and B2B sit on Plus at $499.

The trade-off is that sophistication costs a lot here. Growave suits stores that want loyalty, reviews, and a wishlist from one vendor, especially if they’re already paying for a reviews app separately.

Love Loyalty

Love Loyalty makes one product and prices it to win comparisons. Points, referrals, VIP tiers, paid memberships, B2B segments, bonus campaigns, and wallet passes all come in at $79 a month, $120 less than Growave charges for its tiers alone.

Redemption is the deliberate design choice. Customers redeem in the cart in two steps, and free-product rewards drop straight into the cart rather than arriving as a code. Points appear on up to 15 touchpoints, including the product page. On monthly billing, the loyalty page, analytics, POS, and 30+ integrations arrive on the $12 plan rather than the top one.

The trade-off is scope. There are no product reviews and no wishlist, so a merchant leaving Growave keeps paying for those somewhere else. Love Loyalty suits brands that already have reviews sorted, especially stores running B2B and D2C together that don’t want to reach a $499 plan to segment customers.

How we compared Growave and Love Loyalty

We wanted to know when a bundle beats a specialist on total cost, and which loyalty features each app makes you pay up for.

  • Features: Rewards, tiers, memberships, POS, wallet passes, reviews and wishlist, languages, B2B, and API access, and the plan that unlocks each.
  • Pricing: Every published plan, order limit, and overage block, priced at ten order volumes.
  • Integrations: Connector counts per plan, Shopify Flow, and Klaviyo.
  • Merchant feedback: Shopify App Store reviews and their star distribution, plus our study of 3,410 loyalty app reviews.
  • Migration: What moves between the two, and what stays behind when you leave a bundle.

We read both Shopify App Store listings, growave.io/pricing, and loveloyalty.app/pricing on 11 November 2026. Overage costs are our own calculations from each vendor’s published blocks.

Growave vs Love Loyalty: At a glance

GrowaveLove Loyalty
Best forStores replacing separate reviews and wishlist appsStores that want loyalty only, at the lowest price
What you getLoyalty, reviews, wishlist, and UGCLoyalty only
Entry priceFree, then $15/moFree, then $12/mo
Free plan200 orders/mo, with Growave branding150 orders/mo
Free trial14 days on paid plans14 days on paid plans
Annual discountNone published17% to 25%
Built for ShopifyYesYes
App Store rating4.8 from 1,287 reviews5.0 from 427 reviews
One-star reviews30 (2%)None
On the App Store since14 July 201424 October 2024
Listing languages16, including French, German, and JapaneseEnglish only
Shopify POSFrom $15/moFrom $12/mo on monthly billing
VIP tiersFrom $199/moFrom $79/mo
Wallet passesFrom $199/moFrom $79/mo
B2B loyaltyFrom $499/moFrom $79/mo
API accessFrom $499/mo (API and SDK)From $399/mo
Top published plan$999/mo, unlimited orders$399/mo, unlimited orders

Love Loyalty keeps the loyalty features cheaper. Growave covers more jobs under one subscription and has the longer track record and broader language support. The next section shows where those differences affect the way a store actually runs.

How do Growave and Love Loyalty compare on features?

Start with the jobs you need the app to handle. Growave makes more sense when reviews and wishlists are part of the project. Love Loyalty makes more sense when loyalty is the whole job and you want tiers, memberships, or B2B without moving to a high-priced plan. A few differences matter much more than the full feature list.

Do you need reviews and a wishlist from the same app?

Only Growave offers them. Product reviews with attributes, review request emails, Google Shopping reviews, Instagram UGC, a wishlist, and back-in-stock emails are spread across its free, $15, and $199 plans. Love Loyalty has no reviews product and no wishlist.

So if a reviews app and a wishlist app are on your current bill, add them up before you compare anything else. That total, not the loyalty price, is what Growave is competing with.

Best for: Growave, by a distance. It’s the only section it wins outright.

Which app makes VIP tiers and memberships cheaper?

Love Loyalty puts VIP tiers and paid memberships both on its $79 Growth plan. Its one-click membership upsell applies the benefits to the same order, and membership sales carry a 1.8% fee

Growave puts tiers and points expiry on Growth at $199 and has no paid-membership product. You can build something membership-like from tiers, store credit, and Boost campaigns, but you can’t sell a recurring plan.

Best for: Love Loyalty. A recurring membership line at $79 is the biggest structural difference between these two apps.

Which app is better for POS and wallet passes?

Love Loyalty, on price. It offers in-store earning and redemption from $12 a month on monthly billing (Growth at $59 if you pay annually), and Apple and Google Wallet passes from $79. Growave starts POS and Shopify Flow at $15, and adds a POS loyalty QR code, wallet passes, and store credit at the till on Growth at $199.

Growave’s in-store story is broader because the wishlist and reviews come with it. But if you’re comparing loyalty across POS and online alone, Love Loyalty gets you there for less.

Best for: Love Loyalty for price. Growave if store credit at the till matters to you.

Which app supports more languages?

This is an easy decision for a multilingual store. Growave lists 16 languages, including French, German, Japanese, Portuguese, Spanish, Korean, and both Chinese variants. Love Loyalty lists English only.

For a store selling in a second language, this ends the comparison.

Best for: Growave.

Which app is better for B2B loyalty?

Love Loyalty makes B2B segmentation easier to justify. Its $79 Growth plan lets wholesale and retail customers follow different rules in the same store.

Best for: Love Loyalty. A wholesale and retail split is a $79 problem here and a $499 one on Growave.

How do points, rewards, and referrals compare?

For a basic points-and-referrals program, Love Loyalty gives you more at the lower end. Referrals are available on its free plan, while Growave includes them from $15 with fraud protection. Love Loyalty redeems in the cart with free products added directly and lists store credit and cash back as reward types, with checkout extensions at $399.

Growave’s engine is more flexible at the top. Store credit and gift cards arrive at $199, and custom reward actions and checkout extensions at $499.

Best for: Love Loyalty for most stores. Growave if you need custom reward actions and can justify $499.

Which app connects to more tools?

Love Loyalty. Its $12 plan includes Klaviyo, Shopify Flow, and 30+ integrations on monthly billing, and its API costs $399. Growave allows one integration on Entry at $15 and unlimited integrations on Plus at $499, which is also where its API and SDK sit. Shopify Flow is included from $15.

Whichever you pick, check what syncs to Klaviyo before you rebuild flows around it.

Best for: Love Loyalty. Thirty connectors at $12 against one at $15 isn’t close.

Which app has better support?

It’s a tie, split by store size. Love Loyalty offers live chat on every plan, including free, plus founder-led onboarding on Plus, and its co-founder replies to reviews publicly. Growave starts with 48-hour email on the free plan, moves to 24/7 email and chat from $15, and adds phone support, a customer success manager, and a launch plan at $499.

Best for: Love Loyalty for a small store that wants help sooner. Growave for a large store that wants a dedicated success manager, which Love Loyalty doesn’t offer at any price.

Which app has better reporting?

Love Loyalty. Analytics and reports start on its $12 plan. Growave has dashboards inside the app, with none listed on the free plan and API access only from $499.

Best for: Love Loyalty, on both price and access.

How much do Growave and Love Loyalty cost?

Both apps set order limits on their paid plans, then add charges in 100-order blocks on some tiers. That makes the advertised monthly price a starting point. The examples below show what happens when your store grows past the allowance.

Growave pricing

PlanCostOrder limitBest for
Free$0200/moLoyalty, wishlist, and reviews on a live store
Entry$15/mo500/mo, then $20 per extra 100Rewards, referrals, POS, and Flow
Growth$199/mo1,500/mo, then $15 per extra 100Tiers, wallet passes, UGC, and back-in-stock emails
Plus$499/mo3,000/mo, then $10 per extra 100Checkout extensions, API and SDK, and B2B
Unlimited$999/moNo limitHigh-volume stores that want a fixed bill

Love Loyalty pricing

PlanCostOrder limitBest for
Free$0150/moTesting a real points program
Professional$12/mo, or $10/mo billed annually with fewer features500/moLoyalty page, analytics, POS, and 30+ integrations (monthly billing)
Growth$79/mo, or $708/yr2,000/mo, then $15 per extra 100Tiers, memberships, B2B, and wallet passes
Plus$399/mo, or $3,588/yrUnlimitedCheckout extensions, API, and founder onboarding

A few things to know before you budget:

  • Leave Growave Entry before about 1,400 orders: At $20 per extra 100, Entry plus overage passes the flat $199 Growth price at roughly 1,420 orders a month.
  • Look for Growave’s Unlimited plan on its own site: The $999 plan is on growave.io, but the App Store card only says “See all pricing options”.
  • Don’t expect an annual discount from Growave: It publishes none, and App Store billing runs every 30 days. Love Loyalty takes about 25% off Growth and Plus when you pay yearly.
  • Pay monthly for Love Loyalty Professional: At $10 a month on annual billing, it loses POS, integrations, and analytics, which reappear on Growth at $59.
  • Budget for Love Loyalty’s membership fee: It takes 1.8% of membership sales on Growth.

Which free plan gives you more?

Growave’s is larger, at 200 orders a month, and it isn’t a trial. Loyalty points, the wishlist, and product reviews all run, with data import and export. The catches are Growave branding on your storefront and 48-hour email support, the slowest response time either vendor offers.

Love Loyalty’s free plan covers 150 orders with points, two-step cart redemption, referrals, full customisation, and live chat. It leaves out tiers, the loyalty page, free-product rewards, points expiry, analytics, POS, and integrations. That’s enough to launch on and not enough to grow on.

So a store at exactly 200 orders gets a free program from Growave and a $12 bill from Love Loyalty. At 300 orders, it’s $15 against $12. Both are worth testing alongside other free Shopify loyalty apps before you pay.

How do costs change as order volume grows?

The sticker price matters less than what each app charges at your order volume, once overage blocks are counted. These are our calculations from each vendor’s published 2026 prices.

Orders/monthGrowaveLove LoyaltyCheaper option
200Free, $0Professional, $12Growave
500Entry, $15Professional, $12Love Loyalty by $3
1,000Entry with overage, $115Growth, $79Love Loyalty by $36
1,500Growth, $199Growth, $79Love Loyalty by $120
2,000Growth with overage, $274Growth, $79Love Loyalty by $195
2,500Growth with overage, $349Growth with overage, $154Love Loyalty by $195
3,000Growth with overage, $424Growth with overage, $229Love Loyalty by $195
4,200Growth with overage, $604Plus, $399Love Loyalty by $205
5,000Plus with overage, $699Plus, $399Love Loyalty by $300
10,000Unlimited, $999Plus, $399Love Loyalty by $600

Love Loyalty is cheaper at every paid volume here, and Growave only wins the 200-order row. Plan for the crossovers inside each ladder too. On Growave, Growth and Plus both cost $649 at 4,500 orders, Plus is cheaper above that, and Plus reaches the $999 Unlimited price at 8,000 orders. On Love Loyalty, Growth with overage hits $409 at 4,200 orders, so move to the $399 Plus plan before then.

What do merchants say about Growave and Love Loyalty?

Growave’s record is long and includes its bad years. Love Loyalty’s is short and has been written entirely during a growth phase. Ratings were checked on 11 November 2026.

SourceGrowaveLove Loyalty
Shopify App Store4.8 from 1,287 reviews5.0 from 427 reviews
G221 reviewsNo G2 page

Growave’s positive reviews cluster around consolidation and migration, which is what people buy it for. The newest, from TIME2DRINK on 10 November 2026, is a long account of a membership-style program launch that names the account manager who ran it. Its 2% one-star tail is the honest picture of a twelve-year-old bundle, and it’s public, so you can read the worst cases before you buy.

Love Loyalty’s reviews are recent and specific. Fargro in the UK described an earning-method display bug that support fixed the same week, in November 2026.

What our Shopify loyalty app review research found

Our study of 3,410 Shopify App Store reviews covered both apps. Growave’s 180 written reviews in the sample mentioned support 139 times, with 130 compliments and 3 complaints. It had 8 one- or two-star reviews, split between bugs (3), slow or unhelpful support (2), and problems uninstalling (2). Setup drew more complaints than most themes, 4 of its 33 mentions.

Love Loyalty’s 186 written reviews mentioned rewards mechanics in 52.2% of cases, against a 27.2% category average, and customisation in 24.2%, close to double the average. Its 112 support mentions included 110 compliments, and it had no one- or two-star reviews in the study period. With BON Loyalty, it was the app merchants most often said they’d switched to, in 8 reviews.

The same study found reviewers with more than a year on an app were about twice as likely to leave one or two stars. That’s why Growave’s tail and Love Loyalty’s clean sheet aren’t quite comparable yet.

Growave support and consolidation earn the praise, and the complaints are few but real. Whereas Love Loyalty: Merchants like the rewards and the look, and the record is still young.

How do you migrate between Growave and Love Loyalty?

Leaving a bundle takes more planning than leaving a standalone loyalty app. With Growave, reviews and wishlists are part of the move too, so decide where those jobs will live before you switch.

Neither listing names the other as a supported source, so a move either way is a manual export and import. Love Loyalty’s support has handled historical points imports by CSV, and Growave’s reviews often praise its migration help, though it isn’t sold as a priced service, so ask before you sign.

ItemGrowave to Love LoyaltyLove Loyalty to Growave
Points balancesExport to CSV and importExport to CSV and import
Tier statusRecalculate from spend, since tiers count differentlyRecalculate from spend, and tiers need Growave Growth at $199
Referral historyAttribution chains are lostAttribution chains are lost
Wallet passesReissue and ask members to add the new passReissue and ask members to add the new pass
Product reviews and wishlistsStay behind, so keep a separate reviews appNot applicable
Paid membershipsNot applicableNo equivalent product, so members need another plan
  1. Export points balances and tier assignments to CSV before you cancel anything.
  2. Leaving Growave, decide where your product reviews will live first. Your review history has years of SEO value, and it won’t move into an app that doesn’t do reviews.
  3. Ask customers to redeem pending referral credit, because referral attribution won’t carry over.
  4. Rebuild tiers from spend in the new app rather than copying tier names across.
  5. Email every wallet-pass holder with the new pass.
  6. Run both programs in parallel for one billing cycle, with only one app issuing points, then uninstall the old one.

If you’re leaving Growave mainly for loyalty pricing, look at Growave alternatives that still bundle reviews, so the review history has somewhere to go.

Which Shopify loyalty app should you choose?

Three questions settle it.

Are you paying for a reviews app or a wishlist app right now? If so, add those bills to Love Loyalty’s price before comparing, because Growave’s $199 already includes them.

Do you need paid memberships or B2B segments? Both cost $79 on Love Loyalty, against $199 to $499 on Growave, and Growave doesn’t sell paid memberships at all.

How much does a long review history matter to you? Growave has 30 one-star reviews you can read before you buy. Love Loyalty has none written yet, partly because it’s young.

Your store or requirementRecommended appWhy choose it?
Under 200 orders a monthGrowaveFree plan covers 200 orders
200 to 500 orders, loyalty onlyLove Loyalty$12 a month on Professional
500 to 4,000 orders, loyalty onlyLove LoyaltyTiers, memberships, and B2B at $79
Replacing separate reviews and wishlist appsGrowaveAll three on one bill
Selling in a language other than EnglishGrowave16 listing languages
In-store and online, on a budgetLove LoyaltyPOS and wallet passes from $12 and $79
B2B without a $499 planLove LoyaltyB2B segments on Growth at $79
A dedicated success managerGrowaveIncluded on Plus at $499
Above 8,000 orders, fixed billingLove LoyaltyUnlimited on Plus, $600 a month under Growave Unlimited

Final verdict: Growave or Love Loyalty?

Love Loyalty is the easier choice when loyalty is the main job and your other storefront tools are already in place. Its lower plans make tiers, memberships, and B2B easier to justify.

Growave earns the higher bill when you would otherwise pay for reviews and a wishlist separately, or when you need broader language support. In those cases, consolidating the apps may matter more than the loyalty price.

Before deciding, compare the total cost of the apps you would keep with each option. That’s the number that should settle it

FAQs

Is Growave or Love Loyalty cheaper at 2,000 orders a month?

Love Loyalty. Its Growth plan covers 2,000 orders at $79 a month, or $59 billed annually. Growave’s Growth plan costs $199 and covers 1,500 orders, so at 2,000 you’d pay $274 with overage.

Does Growave have a free plan?

Yes. It covers 200 orders a month with loyalty points, a wishlist, and product reviews, plus data import and export. Growave branding stays on your storefront, and support is by email within 48 hours.

Do both apps support Apple and Google Wallet passes?

Yes, on different plans. Love Loyalty includes them on Growth at $79 a month, and Growave adds them, with a POS loyalty QR code, on Growth at $199. If wallet passes are the centre of your program, Upzelo puts them on every plan with push notifications.

Which has better reviews, Growave or Love Loyalty?

Love Loyalty’s record is cleaner, at 5.0 from 427 reviews with nothing below three stars. Growave’s is longer, at 4.8 from 1,287 reviews since 2014, including 30 one-star reviews you can read in full.

Which is better for B2B loyalty?

Love Loyalty, which includes B2B programs by customer segment on Growth at $79 a month. Growave puts B2B points and wishlists on Plus at $499.

Does Love Loyalty include product reviews?

No. Love Loyalty is a loyalty app only, with no reviews product and no wishlist. If you switch from Growave, you’ll need a separate reviews app to keep collecting and showing reviews.

Can I run both apps at the same time?

Only briefly. Both write points balances and react to the same orders, so customers could earn twice on one purchase. Run them in parallel for one billing cycle at most, with one app issuing points and the other switched to read-only.

D
Written by

Daniel Smith

Tracks the Shopify App Store so everyday merchants don't have to. Having personally vetted, audited, and reviewed hundreds of apps, he cuts through the marketing noise to recommend tools that actually drive revenue. He helps brands build the ultimate lean, high-performing tech stack.